Key West Should Be Known for This, tooHistorians/History
tags: Key West, José Martí
Arlo Haskell is the author of The Jews of Key West: Smugglers, Cigar Makers, and Revolutionaries (1823-1969) (Sand Paper Press, November 2017) and executive director of the Key West Literary Seminar. He is also the author of the poetry collection, Joker, and the editor of poetry volumes by Harry Mathews and Héctor Viel Temperley.
In 1882, José Martí, the exiled Cuban journalist and revolutionary who would soon lead the Cuban independence movement, wrote a series of newspaper editorials describing the refugee crisis in New York, where thousands of Jewish immigrants were seeking safety from persecution under the Russian Empire. “These are grave times for the Jews,” he wrote of the “May Laws” that had been instituted by the tsar and driven Jews into exile. “They have been expelled from Russia, and they are chased through the countryside like wild animals.” As he reported on a heartrending visit to a playground full of Jewish orphans, Martí described the “barbaric and rancorous cause” that had separated young children from their parents, calling it “a crime against humanity that should appall all peoples and grieve the heavens.”
Scenes of Jewish suffering like these helped focus Martí’s attention on the persecution he and other Cuban dissidents had experienced under Spanish rule, and on the exile they faced in the wake of the Ten Years War, the brutal, failed campaign for independence that had ended with Cuban surrender to the Spanish in 1876. Writings on Jewish themes eventually helped Martí galvanize an unexpected group of supporters to his nationalist cause. The most significant of his surprise alliances unfolded during the 1890s in the Jewish community of Key West, Florida, where dozens of Jews joined the Cuban Revolutionary Party and funneled weapons to the rebel forces that would finally end Spanish rule over Cuba.
Nationalist movements typically emphasize a fierce sense of group identity that can unite its members over a perceived other. But Martí’s nationalism was different, with a powerful message that welcomed disparate ethnic and national groups. “No man has any special rights because he belongs to one race or another,” he wrote. “’Cuban’ means more than white, more than mulatto, more than black.” Invoking the Jewish diaspora, he warned his followers that exile could become a permanent condition. “We are Jews in point of fortune,” he wrote, “and we hope always for a Messiah who never comes. There is only one way to see the Messiah come, and that is to sculpt him with your own hands,” he said. “We will be brave, or we will wander. We will finally put our efforts to the test, or we will be outcasts, roaming the world from one country to another.”
The island city of Key West was an ideal laboratory for Martí’s experiment in pan-national nationalism. A nominally American city in a former Confederate state, Key West exhibited strikingly progressive politics. During and after the Ten Years War, thousands of Cuban exiles had settled on this five-square-mile mass of limestone, where many found work in a cigar-making industry that had been transformed by powerful Jewish manufacturers including Samuel Seidenberg and Pincus Pohalski. Voters here elected the son of a Cuban revolutionary hero as their mayor and delivered two Cuban natives to the state legislature in Tallahassee. Black men held the offices of county sheriff and county judge. Dozens of immigrant Jewish peddlers from Romania, Lithuania, Poland, and elsewhere throughout Eastern Europe settled here after the great fire of 1886. They established political and social organizations like the Jewish Alliance and participated in the thriving economy that made Key West, for a time, the wealthiest city, per-capita, in the nation.
When Martí arrived in Key West on New Year’s Day of 1892, he was already well known as a charismatic speaker and was gaining respect as a savvy political organizer. As he solidified his leadership over the Cuban Revolutionary Party and raised funds for the revolution, he also broadened his political base, adding Jewish immigrants and Anglo-American sympathizers to the white and black Cuban factory workers who had long been his most ardent followers. One of Martí’s most important Jewish supporters was Edward Steinberg, a successful proprietor of a local dry goods store, who hosted the lavish reception that followed Martí’s historic New Year’s Day rally and arranged for Martí to give a private address to the Jewish Alliance.
Another crucial ally in Martí’s cultivation of Jewish support was General Carlos Roloff Mialofsky, a Polish-Jewish veteran of the Cuban revolutionary forces who had survived the Ten Years War. The multilingual Mialofsky (he is said to have been fluent in seven languages) met frequently with local Jewish leaders, developing working relationships between party chiefs and the Yiddish-, Russian-, Lithuanian-, and Polish-speaking Jews of Key West. A major speech Mialofsky gave in Key West clarified the argument for Jewish support of the Cuban cause. “Compatriots, I am the son of unfortunate Poland…. Destiny has been adverse to us … but because I cannot offer my life for the country of my birth, I put all of my efforts for the freedom of that other land where I have lived among heroic men.” It went without saying that Spain, which had persecuted Jews for centuries under the Inquisition, was the common enemy of Cubans and Jews alike.
Under the direction of Martí and Mialofsky, Key West’s Jewish leaders organized Club Abrabanel, a secret cell of the Cuban Revolutionary Party that operated as an underground arms dealer to Martí’s forces, buying guns, ammunition, and explosives and delivering them in sailing schooners to the rebels fighting in Cuba. Named for Don Isaac Abrabanel, the Jewish statesman and financier who had resisted the Inquisition in fifteenth-century Portugal, the group’s members believed they were continuing Abrabanel’s struggle, chasing Spain from the new world and taking revenge for the diaspora it had initiated. Louis Fine, who founded and led services at Key West’s Roidef Sulim, the first Jewish congregation in South Florida, explained that his actions in Club Abrabanel were “a part of Jewish vengeance against Spain, the old persecutor of the race.”
One Cuban general who was familiar with the Jewish community’s wartime efforts remarked: “When it came time to serve Cuba, they were themselves Cubans. They placed Cuba before their own homeland, and therefore they did so much more than Cubans.” Jews in Key West maintained their support even as Martí was killed in battle, and during the early years of independence many resettled in Cuba, where they hoped to see the realization of his egalitarian vision. Unfortunately, as the Cuban state matured, Martían idealism gave way to a harder and more typical nationalism. Racial relations among whites and blacks remained relatively progressive in early-twentieth-century Cuba, but Jews often found themselves, again, as outcasts.
For a fleeting but critical moment, José Martí and the Jews of Key West had shown the dramatic potential of a populist movement founded upon an ideology of equality and human rights. “With all, and for the good of all” had been Martí's rallying cry, and in the Jews of Key West he had found committed idealists who would put his words into action.
comments powered by Disqus
- Haitian Americans Reclaim the Traditions of Vodou from Centuries of Misperception
- DeSantis Proposes Surveying Students, Faculty on Political Views
- Philly Plan for Tubman Memorial Draws Fire: Were Black Artists Excluded?
- One Absurdity of Texas's Divisive Concepts Law? Call to Rename Slave Trade as "Involuntary Relocation"
- 3 Law Profs: Connecting Abortion and Voting Rights at SCOTUS
- If "Heathen" Sounds Outdated, Historian Kathryn Gim Lum Says it Still Explains Racism in America
- How The Court Just Changed America
- The Crisis Historian Has Bad News About the Crisis
- Joint OAH-AHA Statement on Dobbs Decision
- Academics Worry Florida's Academic Legislation is Coming to the Rest of the Nation