The Commemoration of D-Day Forgot One War Veterans' Group: IndiansRoundup: Talking About History
David Yeagley, adjunct professor at the University of Oklahoma College of
Liberal Studies, in frontpagemag.com (June 1, 2004):
Im still an American Indian patriot. Even after watching CNNs 90 minute program featuring the May 29 dedications of the new National WWII Memorial in Washington, D.C., I still love this country, more than ever.
No, I didnt hear one mention of the American Indian. No one acknowledged themore than 190,000 living American Indian veterans, who represent nearly one out of every ten Indians. I didnt hear any praise for the unique contribution Indians have made in all war efforts of the twentieth century.
I heard instead repeated praise of black, Hispanic, and Japanese Americans and their contributions to the war effort, and American society in general.
Indeed, the featured musical moment of the program, was given to a black female, Denyse Graves, mezzo soprano opera singer. They could have chosen Barbara McAllister, a tall Cherokee mezzo, who is older but well-known in New York opera circles.
Barry Black, the black chaplain of the U.S. Senate, gave the benediction. Apparently there no longer any living descendents of the white Sons of the Revolution who can pray; no, Blacks skin gave him special authority. Barry Black didnt mention the name Jesus Christ. Would that name have blurred his image?
After the program, Paula Zahn interviewed Martha S. Putney, a black female historian. Putney talked about black female contributions to the war effort. Paula apparently didnt know Indian women veterans exist.
One got the impression that blacks now constitute the core definition of what it means to be an American. Somehow, they have become the quintessential carrier of American values. The memorial service was like an ethnic pride parade in Washington, another Million Man March.
But what is the image of blacks at least as expressed by so-called black leaders in this country? The demagogues proclaim the message: America wronged me. You need to make it right. You need to put me on a pedestal, along with the greatest heroes of white American history. The image of blacks is a complaint, a cry for equality. It is a plea for acceptance, and an expression of utter dependency.
This isnt patriotism.
So, what is the Indian image? Before white liberals distorted it into another version of Ive been wronged and added new images of casino corruption, vice, and greed, the Indian image used to be about bravery, self-sacrifice, and independence. The great Indian warrior never needed equality, applause or acceptance.
Maybe CNN still regards the Indian like that; they certainly offered none.
After the CNN program, I realized, as never before, the American Indian is not part of the modern media image of America. The National WWII Memorial program proved that. The Indian warrior image is out even at such moment, at such a memorial service for soldiers. Blacks, Hispanics, and Japanese are Americas new warriors now; the media says so.
For me to call myself an American Indian patriot is a real stretch at times like this. How can I love the country so much, when it insults me in return, and instead honors people who never won anything in battle against the American Indian?
Its simple: America is the most grand and beautiful country in the world and its built on Indian land. I instinctively claim America as my own. Never mind media images: the foreigners society that developed here is like an adopted son, thats all. He washed ashore here as a lost infant. We Indians raised him. He grew into the mightiest of the earth. As an Indian, cant I be proud?
But for me to love America, I must overlook the Indian holocaust. I must wink at the horrors of yesterday. To have a positive outlook on life, I must immediately forgive my enemies today. This I must do, like no other race in America must do. American Indians were destroyed on our own land, in our own home. More is required of us, spiritually, than of any other people.
Indians must be superior. Just the basic feeling of loving America requires a miraculous transcendence of other races. If we do not achieve this, we consign ourselves to abject tragedy and disquietude. We are Ghost Dancers, forever.
Perhaps I should be grateful that CNN and the program planners did not include
the Indian. That doesnt just mean that Indians are excluded, or that America
simply cant manage its collective guilt toward the Indian. It might mean
that America has an unspoken feeling that Indians really are superior. We are
on a higher plane. We are unmentioned because we are not seen in the nether
regions where the media dwell.
comments powered by Disqus
Vernon Clayson - 6/10/2004
I know this is beating a dead horse but in the media's eye the Indian is of no more consequence than the average white man, think of it, the Indian and the white man finally lumped together. I saw an instance this morning in the coverage of the Reagan viewing at the Rotunda of the Capitol that is a prime example. An Indian in full regalia and brandishing an eagle feather walked by the flag covered casket and the announcer said "There's an-an-
an-other person in the long line of viewers. He could, or would, not say "Indian", however, had it been any other race, except a white man, of course, he would have gone into paroxysms of praise on how beloved Reagan was by that particular race or culture. Indians are like non-complaining white people, invisible to the media and
Vernon Clayson - 6/5/2004
Prof. Yeagley, Would you have the Indian seek attention, and riches, in the manner of the Jesse Jacksons, the Louis Farrakans and the Al Sharptons, to say nothing of the Bill Clintons, the Dick Cheneys, even the Billy Grahams and most Hollywood actors. Is it not better that the Indian people continue as dignified and thoughtful individuals in the moral majority, those who live without casting themselves, ourselves, as victims of this or that prejudice. Do not wait for the media to single out an Indian for notice, it is enough to know that they are included in the thousands of otherwise unnoticed individual Americans, some perhaps having an axe to grind, conduct themselves honorably and with dignity and with lattle fanfare. A good example is Lori Piestewa,a Hopi, and a soldier, lost in combat in Iraq. You should notice that no tall tales, i.e., exagerated claims, were made about her experience and death. I'm sure her family and her people would have had it no other way. Would you really want someone like Jackson, Farrakan or Sharpton droning on endlessly and self-righteously about the injustice of it all?
- How Clinton Could Respond on Supreme Court Vacancy
- Trump and Clinton Way Ahead in South Carolina
- McConnell Says Senate Will Wait to Replace Scalia
- Antonin Scalia Is Dead
- Clinton Says Sanders Would Be Threat to Obama Legacy
- Internal Tracker Shows Trump Leading in South Carolina
- How the Primaries are Rigged Against Sanders
- Carson Sees Fundraising Resurgence
- Trump Has GOP Mega Donors Frozen
- Quote of the Day
- Top GOP Candidates Haven’t Released Tax Returns
- Trump Attack Ads Finally Begin
- Super PACs Gear Up for Clinton
- Cruz App Mines Data from Your Phone
- Trump Way Ahead in South Carolina
- Ben Carson used an apparently fake Joseph Stalin quote — and the Internet loved it
- Rubio exaggerates in saying it's been 80 years since a 'lame duck' made a Supreme Court nomination
- Humans Hard-Wired to Teach, Anthropologist Says
- Parents outraged after students shown ‘white guilt’ cartoon for Black History Month
- Maryland is once again considering retiring its state song
- Historian at the center of Sanders-Clinton debate
- James Loewen Says Additional Baltimore Confederate Statues Should be Removed
- NYT History Book Reviews: Who Got Noticed this Week?
- A historian’s advice to students thinking of getting a PhD in a tough economic climate
- German historian Heinz Richter cleared of charges