Clarence Page: Why Isn't There a White History Month?
Clarence Page, in the Chicago Tribune (Feb. 25, 2004):
Black History Month was never intended to make people uncomfortable--unless maybe they ought to be.
Nevertheless, despite the best of intentions, a misunderstanding of what the month is all about can lead sometimes to a whopper of an embarrassment.
That's sort of what happened recently at Connecticut's Suffield High School when a group of sociology students decided to hang posters around the school to promote April as"White History Month."
Shortly after they were nabbed, the five students explained to their upset principal, Thomas Jones, that, alas, it was all a misunderstanding, according to The Hartford Courant. The students had been assigned to"explore the effect of rumors." They decided the posters would be a real nifty way to do that. Needless to say, their experiment triggered a lot of rumors, especially in the school's small but understandably alarmed black student population.
The principal scolded the white students for their insensitivity and turned them over to a teacher who reportedly specializes in civil rights and cultural sensitivity issues. In this way, the school at large was able to turn the incident into what one school board official called a"teachable moment," an opportunity to educate both offenders and the offended about differences in how the world looks through each other's eyes.
Good for them. No long-term harm done, I hope. This particular high school poster flap is the most embarrassing incident related to Black History Month that I can recall since early 2001. That was when then-Virginia Gov. Jim Gilmore revoked a proclamation declaring May to be"European Heritage and History Month." The governor had learned to his deep dismay that the request for the commemoration had come from a white separatist group headed by former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke. Such an embarrassment.
But you don't need to be a klansman, past or present, to ask"Why don't we have a White History Month?" I've heard that question quite a few times over the years. So have other black people I know. Some of us have come up with a list of appropriate responses to it, such as:
1."Because every month is white history month."
2."Because white history has not been lost, stolen or suppressed over the years as much as black history has."
4."History is taught so poorly in our schools these days that maybe we should have a white history month."
5."That's right. I said, `Yo' mama'!!!"
Now, now. We should all try to manage our anger at such moments. Such encounters reveal precisely what Black History Month was intended to remedy: an ignorance about history--black and otherwise. That's why I oppose so-called"political correctness." We need more dialogue, not less....
when the late black scholar Carter G. Woodson dreamed up what was then called Negro History Week in 1926, he too dreamed of the day when it no longer would be needed.
He imagined a day when every student's education would include such African-American figures as Crispus Attucks, who died in the Boston Massacre; Matthew A. Henson, who co-discovered the North Pole with Robert Peary, and Benjamin Banneker, the pioneer scientist who helped conduct the first survey of Washington.
It was important, Woodson felt, that African-Americans understand that we had more to our history than our victimization. In fact, there was a much greater all-American story to be told in how mightily many of our ancestors had triumphed despite adversity.
Woodson imagined a day when the contributions of people from various races, ethnicities and, for that matter, genders would be taught fairly and properly. Then Americans might move more swiftly toward a society where such differences would no longer matter.
Unfortunately, history seems to be given such a low priority in today's schools that I sometimes wonder whether Woodson's dream day is slipping further away.
comments powered by Disqus
Tim Moore - 4/1/2006
Why is there no white history month? Because it would cause an outrage. It would be the same if there was a white Miss America pageant or an NAAWP or how about a WET (White Entertainment Channel? Why would a White History Month be any different? The world hates white people and if you are an American, Male, Christian and White - you are the most hated person in the world.
todd god god - 4/30/2005
Maybe when we stop dividing each other along racial lines we'll start to accept each other as people.
Chistopher Brian Keezler - 2/4/2005
Should each race have their month of celebration? If that were so, almost every month of the year would be designated for holiday recognition. I'm not too sure if thats necessary. Maybe history isn't taught throughly enought in our school systems, but thats a issue all in it's own. Do we feel victimized or threatened enough to declare a specific month to be White History Month? Should Whites need a recovery period of a month for a character/slef-esteem boost and to learn about valued ancestors.
Devon Robert Smith - 9/22/2004
I think that it is a shame that those students got into trouble for being WHITE AND PROUD! Being White, I of course know NOTHING about MY heritage, because teacher's were always too busy trying to teach BLACK & HISPANIC crap to us! And just what in the hell do the black population want us to do?? I mean, think about it.. If we had not brought them to America, where would they be right now? They'd be right down in Africa dieing of AIDS with the rest of their "Brothas" and "Sistas".. You liberals keep on dogging the White race and supporting these minority's... We'll see where it gets us in the next 30-40 years from now.... SCARY THOUGHT!
- NYT History Book Reviews: Who Got Noticed this Week?
- Researchers have discovered a previously unknown 149-page manuscript defending homosexuality.
- What Counts as Historical Evidence? The Fracas over John Stauffer’s Black Confederates
- Harvard’s Drew Faust says the Civil War marked the start of large-scale industrial war, not WW I