Edwin Black: Denounces Google and others for operating in China





Google last month launched a version of its extremely popular search engine that prevents Internet users in China from seeing content that has not been government-sanitized, regarding such sensitive subjects as the Tiananmen Square protests, the banned Falun Gong religious group and the suppression of Tibet's independence movement.

Microsoft shut down a blog on its popular MSN network by a Chinese journalist who was critical of the Chinese government.

Rep. Chris Smith (R-N.J.), chairman of House Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights and International Operations, compared Yahoo's actions to alerting the Nazis to whereabouts of Anne Frank.

When a Microsoft executive gave subcommittee members what has become a standard response for the industry ("We comply with legally binding orders whether it's here in the U.S. or China."), Rep. Tom Lantos (D-Calif.), a Holocaust survivor, also heard echoes from the past. "Well, IBM complied with legal orders when they cooperated with Nazi Germany," Lantos said. "Those were legal orders under the Nazi German system. ... Do you think that IBM during that period had something to be ashamed of?"

The Microsoft executive declined to answer, pleading ignorance of IBM's work with the Nazis.

But Edwin Black, the author of "IBM and the Holocaust," heard striking echoes of IBM's defense of its work with Adolf Hitler in the 1930s, which provided the tools that eventually helped keep the wheels of the Holocaust running on time.

"IBM tried to be good Nazis in Germany and good Americans in the United States," Black, the child of Holocaust survivors, told me in a telephone interview. "Google [and the other Internet companies want] to be good Americans in the U.S. and good collaborators in China. They want it both ways, but there are certain things we must not do."

Smith has introduced a bill that would limit the ability of Internet companies to do business in China and other nations that the State Department judges to be repressive. That could mean, for example, moving network servers outside of China, even though that would slow down Internet service in an industry that prides itself on speed.

The State Department also has launched a task force to advise Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice on ways to fight China's exploitation of American technology.

As one who believes in the liberating powers of information technologies, I hope the Internet companies wo`n't wait for government intrusion. I hope they will take it upon themselves to use their considerable leverage to stand up to China's cyber-censors and tear down what many are calling the "Great Firewall" of China.



comments powered by Disqus

Subscribe to our mailing list