Limbo, an Afterlife Tradition, May Be Doomed by the Vatican
But limbo, that netherworld of unbaptized babies and worthy pagans, is very much on the way out - another lesson that while belief in God may not change, the things people believe about him most certainly do.
This month, 30 top theologians from around the world met at the Vatican to discuss, among other quandaries, the problem of what happens to babies who die without baptism. They do not like the word for it, but what they were really doing, as theological advisers to Pope Benedict XVI, was finally disposing of limbo - a concept that was never official church doctrine but has been an enduring medieval theory of a blissful state among the departed, somehow different from both heaven and hell.
Unlike purgatory, a sort of waiting room to heaven for those with some venial faults, the theory of limbo consigned children outside of heaven on account of original sin alone. As a concept, limbo has long been out of favor anyway, as theologically questionable and unnecessarily harsh. It is hard to imagine depriving innocents of heaven. These days it prompts more snickers than anything, as evidenced by the titter of press coverage here along the lines of "Limbo Consigned to Hell."
comments powered by Disqus
Michael Beatty - 12/29/2005
One explanation for "limbo" that I've heard is that it is the first person singular conjugation of the verb limbare, "to know not" - that is, "I know not." Supposedly, when Thomas Aquinas was going over and editing a draft of the Summa theologica, working with a secretary, the secretary would put questions to Aquinas and transcribe his answers.
The story is that when they got to the question of what happens to infants who die before baptism, Aquinas responded, "Limbo." The secretary wrote down the answer, which was picked up in later revisions of the MS and became an accepted, if unofficial teaching, because Aquinas had used an unfamiliar word.
Are there any Latin scholars out there who can help determine if Thomas Aquinas frankly admitted his ignorance as to the fate of unbaptised infants? Has all the controversy over limbo simply been a result of centuries of ignorance over how Aquinas expressed his ignorance?
- Egyptian ‘Mona Lisa’ A Fake
- The Story Behind ‘Woman in Gold’: Nazi Art Thieves and One Painting’s Return
- Scott Walker, Allergic to Dogs, May Run Against Political History
- Russian History Receives a Makeover That Starts With Ivan the Terrible
- Parsing Ronald Reagan’s Words for Early Signs of Alzheimer’s
- Joan Waugh on Grant's and Lee's 'gentlemen's agreement' ending the Civil War
- Charlatan or Sage? Contested Legacy of the late Dr. Ben, a Father of African Studies
- Historians make it easy for visitors to DC to understand the history of the Mall
- History's Grandin Wins Bancroft Prize for "The Empire of Necessity"
- Nobel prize-winning scientist writes a history of science