Historians clash in battle of the sales figuresHistorians in the News
Historian Norman Stone has been drawn into a battle of Amazon rankings after his latest outing was dismissed as "a farrago of errors, half-truths, fantasies, non sequiturs and irrelevancies" by a reviewer.
Reviewing Stone's book, Turkey: A Short History, for the Times Literary Supplement, historian Colin Imber wrote that "Norman Stone lives in Turkey, but this does not necessarily qualify him to write a history of the country", going on to list a range of "errors [which] typify the book". "Professor Stone asserts that 'Mehmet II had already captured the enormous rock fortress overlooking Lake Van ... in the course of his campaign into Iraq'," says Imber, author of The Ottoman Empire, 1300-1650. "Elsewhere in the book, there is no mention of Mehmet II's 'campaign into Iraq', which is just as well, since it exists only in the author's imagination." Imber concludes by saying that "although the quality of this book should have been apparent to any competent editor, it has appeared under the imprint of a respectable publishing house. Let's hope that Thames and Hudson recognise it as a mistake not to be repeated."
Stone, a former speechwriter for Margaret Thatcher and professor of modern history at Oxford now at Turkey's Bilkent University, has hit back at what he calls Imber's "enraged review"....
comments powered by Disqus
- Obama May Create Monument to Gay Rights Movement
- China to release last prisoner jailed over Tiananmen Square protests
- Marine Corps investigating photo of iconic flag-raising on Iwo Jima
- Scholars Blast New Study Tracing Ashkenazi Jews to Khazars of Ancient Turkey
- Legendary Explorer’s Long-Lost Ship May Have Been Found Off Rhode Island
- The Historian Whitewashing Ukraine’s Past
- Andrew Roberts wins $250,000 prize from the conservative Bradley Foundation
- Daniel Aaron, Critic and Historian Who Pioneered American Studies, Dies at 103
- Liz Covart's amazingly popular podcast helps her audience understand early American history
- Justus Rosenberg is still teaching at age 95