Becoming Historians Edited By James Banner and John R. Gillis
comments powered by Disqus
vaughn davis bornet - 12/25/2009
I see this summary/review from many months ago has attracted no comments.
I was startled to see that the assumption here is birth during World War II. Astonishing.
I was of a Generation that received their doctorates in 1948 to, say, 1952. Earlier, we fought in World War II. We did have the GI Bill, thank goodness.
I tell the story in several chapters of my memoir, An Independent Scholar in Twentieth Century America (Talent,Or., Bornet Books,1995.
The scene is Emory University (undergraduate), UGA, and Stanford University (doctorate).
It may be that a close student of this subject will want to look into this material sooner or later.
Let me say right now that getting History degrees in my day was a no kidding process. I am not at all sure I would do it again.
Requirements and standards were unrealistically high, and many faculty behaved, well, not all that decently. (Maybe we were a bit feisty.)
At Stanford, writtens and orals were entirely on subject matter; candidates didn't have a chance. At Berkeley orals were on dissertations; at least a candidate knew more about that tiny subject than did the "committee." (At Stanford, on orals, one faced the whole Department and reps of the minor(s)!Language exams were unrealistically high with flunking not by linguists but subject matter people) just for the hell of it, repeatedly. Prepared in Spanish and in Southern History, I was informed that neither was acceptable, though Latin American majors could offer the former....
The whole thing was an ordeal, first to last, especially because we were all married, with children. Oh well; my account of the joys of higher education long ago can be consulted in full in my memoir.
VAUGHN DAVIS BORNET Ashland, Oregon
- ‘Bite-sized’ history textbooks used in the UK accused of ‘dumbing down’ the subject: should we be worried?
- Tut’s beard glued back on like a bad craft project
- Smithsonian working to finalize deal for new site in London
- The voices of Auschwitz
- What countries teach children about the Holocaust varies hugely
- From his perch in Saudi Arabia, Princeton’s Mark Cohen says Jews and Muslims should remember they used to get along
- Duke honors historian John Hope Franklin with year-long series of events
- What New Left History Gave Us
- Marcus Borg, Liberal Christian Scholar, Dies at 72
- Richard Hofstadter’s insights into the "paranoid style in American politics” lauded in the NYT