The Jury's in at Claremont
At the time, Stanford sociologist Lee Ross said that regardless of who vandalized Dunn's car,"doing this may actually have accomplished some of her goals, if her goal was to make people feel that racism was present and that there was danger of white backlash." He continued,"Sometimes people invent facts because they believe that the conclusion that it would lead people to is true."
This is the educational philosophy of some extreme pro-"diversity" groups nationally, notably the Association of American Colleges and Universities, which argues that working-class and middle-class students need a college education designed to purge them of their ingrained sexist and racist beliefs. It's nice to see this line of thinking didn't carry the day in the jury room.
comments powered by Disqus
Ralph E. Luker - 8/19/2004
Yep, we're in agreement. I was Peter Filene's graduate assistant when he published a major article on "progressivism" which finally pointed out the definitional dilemma.
Robert KC Johnson - 8/19/2004
I agree completely--though the key, of course, comes in how "diversity" is defined. It's a little like "progressivism" in 1970s or 1980s historiography--the phrase was used so much, and meant so many different things to different people, that it became meaningless.
Ralph E. Luker - 8/19/2004
The thrust of criticism here has to be to the fraud that Dunn committed and at the incidental justification for it that Lee Ross apparently offered. Too often, we've allowed certain advocates of diversity to promote illegitimate agendas.
Having said that, we need to be clear about a couple of things: a) diversity in the United States is an empirical reality and the critique of "diversity" can't and shouldn't be intended to change that; b) diversity is difficult, often painful, and proponents of "diversity" too often don't sufficiently acknowledge that reality; and c) diversity does have positive benefits in its challenge to our provincialisms.
- Sources: McMaster Mocked Trump’s Intelligence at a Private Dinner
- The JFK assassination files lead back to Seattle
- Princeton investigates its connection to slavery at a two-day symposium
- Rare Documents Show a Palm Reader's Take on Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt
- A Photo of Billy the Kid Bought for $10 at a Flea Market May Be Worth Millions
- Historian Says Textbooks Have Shaped Our Attitudes On Race
- Heather Ann Thompson says what went on at Attica is worse than we thought
- Princeton’s Jan T. Gross warns that Poland’s showing signs of turning decisively in a fascist direction
- Gar Alperovitz is still pushing to make America more democratic
- Robert Dallek: “The fish rots from the head”