In his acceptance speech McCain intelligently and artfully revealed his own transformation through his Vietnam experience -- from cocky and self-reliant soldier (read, George W. Bush, perhaps) to a humbled servant dedicated to his country. His speech was, ultimately, inspiring.
One thing bugged me though – McCain’s comment on Obama. McCain started to express respect for Obama as an individual (I thought) but then began quoting from the Declaration of Independence about equality and our inalienable rights. That sounded to me as though he was saying that Obama, even though he is black, is an equal – patronizing, I thought, and not called for. But maybe others heard it differently – with politics, I sometimes pick up on the wrong things.
comments powered by Disqus
Jane S. Shaw - 10/25/2008
Thanks (again, my apologies for not responding earlier; I had trouble getting to the comments -- still working on the mechanical details of blogging). For me, five years in a prison camp makes a person a hero, and I give him some slack. That doesn't mean he'd be a good president, but none of our options is good.
Jane S. Shaw - 10/25/2008
Good points. (Allan, I was having trouble reading comments earlier, so I'm just getting to this). I can't remember Cindy's speech although I do remember the video leading up to it, which seemed a bit much.
Ah, we'll see what happens, won't we?
Lester Hunt - 9/8/2008
I just looked at the complete text of the speech, and he brought up their (M's and O's) shared belief that all men are created equal as an example of the fact that what they share in common is more important than what divides them. It didn't look at all like he was saying "even you are my equal." But, like Allan Walstad, even if he had been a bit patronizing toward O, I would have had much more serious problems with the speech than that.
Allan Walstad - 9/7/2008
Sort of like Biden's botched reference to Obama as fresh and "clean" during the primary season? Jane, I wish that a little unseemly patronizing of Obama was the worst of my concerns about McCain or those parts of his speech that a forced myself to listen to. If there was an inspiring speech at the RNC convention, it was Cindy McCain's.
- U.K. Released Hundreds of Nazis After the Holocaust, Says Leading Historian
- NYT History Book Reviews: Who Got Noticed this Week?
- Historians Against the War gathering signatures for new resolution to AHA on alleged violations of academic freedom in Israel
- Academic Seeks Death Certificate for Outlaw Billy the Kid
- Murderer of historian of Czech Jewry goes on trial