RNC Day 1: Nationalism Sometimes Wins as Self-Interest Mingles with Self-Sacrifice
Without trying to minimize the current tribulations of the hurricane-Gustav-tossed regions, and well-aware of the ongoing trauma of Katrina, it is nevertheless easy to mock the sick synergies between hysterical television reporters and posturing politicians on display this holiday weekend. Network anchors often seem downright disappointed when their exaggerated predictions of unprecedented storm damage so frequently are not met; and there are few scenes more cringe-inducing than a convention-hall filled with maudlin politicians trying to outdo each other sentimentally.
Moreover, the strategy worked. So far, the coverage of McCain and the Republicans has been rapturous. President George W. Bush and Vice President Cheney ended up with golden excuses for keeping their low popularity ratings and toxic embrace of the McCain campaign thousands of miles away. And Cindy McCain was spared the humiliation of having her speech compared with Michelle Obama’s silky-smooth superb speech last week.
Less cynically, there is something unsettling about changing procedures in one of the northern-most states when a storm is affecting some of the southern-most states. In politics as in entertainment, the usual instinct is to insist that “the show must go on.” One of American democracy’s glories is that presidential elections have kept to their quadrennial cycle in good times and in bad, during civil war and world wars. Sticking to the routine despite disasters, be they natural or man-made, has great appeal. To start fiddling with the fundamentals of the American political system such as the party conventions unnerves the body politic.
Despite all these concerns, there is something profoundly moving about dramatically changing procedures in one of the northern-most states when a storm is affecting some of the southern-most states. McCain’s sacrifice – and losing four days of television coverage during such a tight race is a sacrifice – helps remind Americans that politics is about more than partisanship. McCain’s gesture – and the hundreds of thousands of dollars Republicans have been donating to flood relief at the convention – affirm that these disparate states remain united, that this country of 300 million people still has a sense of community.
One of the great secrets to American success has been American nationalism, this near magical ability to feel a sense of connection across this vast, diverse, continental empire. There is something delightfully old-fashioned about turning the Republican National Convention into what one Fox News anchor called yet another Labor Day telethon. Before pummeling each other politically, before even choosing a future leader, Americans sometimes need to stop what they are doing, roll up their sleeves, and work together to solve a problem. When people from all over the country gathering in Minneapolis feel the pain of their fellow citizens in New Orleans, America shows that it still works.
We need a politics that can accommodate that kind of communal cooperation even amid partisan combat. We need politicians who can build that sense of community and respond to national crises as national leaders, seeking what is best for our nation, not just for their party.
In fairness, Barack Obama and the Democrats have been equally gracious during this difficult, confusing weekend. But given that John McCain and the Republicans sacrificed more this week, they deserve all the more credit. This campaign has not always produced the kind of high-minded politics both Obama and McCain each have promised, at their respective bests. But this moment of inter-regional sensitivity, national sensibility, and human generosity should be remembered as a highlight, not only of this campaign but of this era, when our focus on individual differences and elite cynicism about nationalism tends to overlook the powerful positive forces keeping Americans together, forging the American nation.
comments powered by Disqus
Raul A Garcia - 9/9/2008
There are rehearsals and the ever-present cameras and posturing by the political actors and the knee-jerk pundits and programmed critics and fawning sycophants. At the local level here in town relief supplies are being ferried to both Haiti, the Turcos islands, and Cuba, by private citzens and religious groups. It is strangely enough, driven only by humanitarian interest and not attached to polls or politics. I have hope.
Arnold Shcherban - 9/6/2008
American mainstream politicians (isn't it a high time to rename them 'eliticians', as they really are?) is one of the most self-congratulating, self-righteous, arrogantly-modest, and ideologically
corrupted (by Pax Amerikana principle and money) kind in the world.
When no else in the world praises them, they have no alternative but praise yourself, otherwise they will die of the lack of serotonin.
Lorraine Paul - 9/5/2008
I hope this is the only person in the US who thinks that his fellow citizens are finer, more noble than those in other countries. Does he think other people around the world don't understand tact, compassion and a duty to protect their own who are in danger from natural disasters.
From a distance, however, the RNC was given a second chance regarding its duty of care to the citizens of New Orleans. Unlike the last time when 'Nero (Bush AND McCain) fiddled while Rome burned'. During Katrina apparently McCain celebrated his birthday!! Good heavens, don't sensible people stop celebrating them after a certain age? Which McCain has definitely reached! Although one could forgive him his big 100, which he is well over halfway to achieving.
As everyone knows, and certainly the people of New Orleans found out this year, just before an election a politician will kiss your "hand", afterwards he will kick it!
- Middle Tenn. State President Wants to Strip Confederate General’s Name From Building
- Trump will get more GOP primary votes than anyone in history (because more people are voting)
- Labour Party suspends former Mayor of London for implying Hitler supported Zionism
- At Virginia home of President Monroe, a sizable revision of history
- Thirty Years After Chernobyl, Debate Rages About Nuclear Power
- The Unconference Movement Grows – And Historians Are Taking the Lead
- New appeal to "Bring Back Military History"
- Former secretary of state Henry Kissinger discusses his controversial career
- Annette Gordon-Reed subjects herself to Reddit, the “anything-goes” social media website
- Historian Nick Turse says the Pentagon has blacklisted him for making multiple FOIA requests