Herbert Spencer on Patriotism
Few individuals in history have received more negative treatment than Herbert Spencer. Some U.S. survey texts give the impression that this alleged “Social Darwinist” (a term Spencer never used) was an apologist for imperialism and violence by the strong against the weak.
Spencer’s own writings tell a different story of a flawed but sincere classical liberal advocate of peace, free exchange, and social cooperation. Spencer was second to none in his critique of imperialism and militarism. In his essay on patriotism, Spencer had this to say about the Afghan War of his time:
Some years ago I gave my expression to my own feeling – anti-patriotic feeling, it will doubtless be called – in a somewhat startling way. It was at the time of the second Afghan war, when, in pursuance of what were thought to be “our interests,” we were invading Afghanistan. News had come that some of our troops were in danger. At the Athenæum Club a well-known military man – then a captain but now a general – drew my attention to a telegram containing this news, and read it to me in a manner implying the belief that I should share his anxiety. I astounded him by replying – “When men hire themselves out to shoot other men to order, asking nothing about the justice of their cause, I don’t care if they are shot themselves.”
comments powered by Disqus
Mark Brady - 5/3/2008
Tim Sydney - 5/3/2008
Funny you should mention Herbert Spencer. By coincidence I came across some other 'kudos' for Herbert from Max Nomad in his 1959 book "Aspects of Revolt". Nomad is definitely a man of the left, but a skeptic of revolutionary dogma. Nomad was a follower (and colleague) of Polish radical Waclaw Machajski. Machajski developed a "James Burnham style" "managerial revolution" style critique of mainstream marxist-leninism and the state socialism well before Burnham put pen to paper. In a chapter entitled "Predictions that came true" Nomad credits Herbert Spencer (along with Karl Marx's rival Michael Bakunin) with being amongst the first to see that a revolutionary socialist state, rather than bringing 'the working class to power', would cement in place a new bureaucratic elite.
- Japanese textbooks may sanitize history, but comic art books don't
- Novels About Real-Life Women Are Saving Forgotten History
- Rubio becomes the first Republican presidential candidate in 2016 to admit US must confront “painful” history of racial discrimination
- CNN documentary focuses on “Nixon’s Own 9/11"
- New documentary lays bare the heated Vidal-Buckley debates of 1968
- Historians Against the War gathering signatures for new resolution to AHA on alleged violations of academic freedom in Israel
- Academic Seeks Death Certificate for Outlaw Billy the Kid
- Murderer of historian of Czech Jewry goes on trial
- Election results are in for the American Historical Association
- Nial Ferguson warns Obama’s bet on Iran has low odds of success