[cross-posted at Austro-Athenian Empire]
Ive been interested in Aaron Burr revisionism for a while. Burr had the bad luck to make enemies of both Jefferson and Hamilton, thus earning the ire of historians across the political spectrum; but Ive long suspected that Burr, like Jefferson and Hamilton, was a complicated mix of good and bad and not the plaster villain hes been cast as. (Besides, a man who wears a locket of Mary Wollstonecraft cant be all bad!)
I just saw a C-Span talk by Nancy Isenberg on her Burr-revisionist book Fallen Founder. The book sounded interesting, and less blindly adulatory of Burr than, say, Roger Kennedys book. (Kennedys Burr, an uncompromising abolitionist hero trying to carve out a territorial enclave of racial and sexual equality, always seemed a bit too good to be true.)
Unfortunately, I was put off by the fact that Isenberg said several things that seemed to me historically dubious:
1. Isenberg said that Hamilton wrote ahead of time that he planned to fire into the air during his duel with Burr. No; he wrote ahead of time that he planned not to fire at all. (Or at least he said that he planned to reserve and throw away his shot. Throw away is ambiguous, I suppose, between firing into the air and not firing, but reserve seems to favour the latter.)
2. She said that James Monroes military interventionism was at odds with the anti-interventionism of his own Monroe Doctrine. No; the Monroe Doctrine was not anti-interventionist quite the contrary.
3. She said that Hamilton was a slaveowner. Maybe; but although Hamilton was complicit in slavery in various ways, as far as I know his actually owning slaves hasnt been proven. (He had black servants, but I dont believe its ever been determined whether they were free or slave. Of course, I havent read her book; perhaps she proves this?)
comments powered by Disqus
Roderick T. Long - 7/29/2007
In related news, does anyone remember that Green Lantern once dueled Aaron Burr?
- Harvard acquires Thoreau's notes on the death of Margaret Fuller
- Big-time Hollywood director makes a movie about Stonewall
- HMS Victory: The mystery of Britain's worst naval disaster is finally solved - 271 years later
- A salute lost to history
- High school senior credited with debunking book by Professor Richard Jensen
- Historians at loggerheads over the AP standards
- Bettany Hughes interview: The historian on how Socrates would have solved Greece's problems
- U.K. Released Hundreds of Nazis After the Holocaust, Says Leading Historian
- NYT History Book Reviews: Who Got Noticed this Week?