George Beres: Review of Joseph Lieberman's The Shooting Game
"Why here?" was the reaction of many when the shooting of students by a fellow student at Oregon's Thurston High School in Springfield grabbed national headlines in May, 1998. The author's study suggests the spring term is the most dangerous time in schools, dating from springs of many years ago.
Fundamental questions are asked in an important book, "The Shooting Game," by Eugene's Joseph Lieberman. It reviews the Thurston shooting in the context of a national-- maybe even global-- pattern: Why does it happen anywhere? Why does it continue to happen?
Concern in Oregon takes on greater immediacy in light of a shooting last February at a high school 60 miles south of Springfield, just a month before publication of Lieberman's book. A 14-year old shot a classmate while they were in the schoolyard of Roseburg High School. His weapon was a handgun smuggled out of his home. A day earlier in the nearby town of Sutherlin, a 15-year old high school boy was arrested for having a loaded handgun in his school locker. Then a week later, four teens were arrested for bringing a gun to school. Amazingly, this was at Springfield High School, only a few miles from Thurston.
Had parents, teachers and school officials been able to read Lieberman's "The Shooting Game" before the Thurston tragedy, it might have been prevented through measures taken at home and at school. Lieberman is an Oregon journalist who has completed the first comprehensive book on causes and history of school shootings dating from 1974. He reveals what he has found to be the linked nature and common roots of school shootings, workplace rampages and suicidal terrorist acts.
Primary focus in the survey of dozens of school shootings and near-shootings in the past three decades is the attack at Thurston. It is the only case where the shooter was arrested the previous day for having a gun in his school locker, and released. Kip Kinkel, then 15, shot to death both his teacher parents at home, before the next day killing two classmates and wounding 25, the largest number in the history of such shootings.
The book (Seven Locks Press) identifies causal similarities from the earliest attacks to the most recent. Its scope crosses international borders with the 2002 school shooting in Erfurt, Germany, that killed 17. As Lieberman connects the dots for many shooting parallels, he offers startling conclusions that must be addressed by schools nationwide to prevent more from occurring. Lieberman suggests how-- when terrifying reality hits close to us-- society needs to study warning signs it ignored for many years. His views are reinforced by Springfield Fire Chief Dennis Murphy, founder of "Ribbon of Promise," national campaign to prevent school violence.
Early reaction to the Thurston shooting was that it came 'without warning." That was not the case, as Lieberman found during three years of research into school shootings. "Thurston," he says, "was a tragedy waiting to happen. That it happened here was an accident of fate which resulted in the teenage gunman being enrolled at Thurston." School shootings that preceded Springfield's indicate they are something more than copycat coincidences. Lieberman has found something deeper at play in the psyches of the involved children. It can involve a thinking mode that causes them to see only one solution to their problems, an option that for a troubled child can become violent. Such a thinking pattern can cause the child to see people as targets, especially if fueled by years of playing video games with violent themes.
His research reveals a seasonal pattern in school shootings that should make teachers and administrators especially alert at this time of year. The Thurston shooting in May was one of a national series of eight successive shootings that occurred in the season when the school year comes to a close.
If our civilization is to survive, he writes, we must study, recognize and learn to cope with the violence that overtakes some children, and which can be symptomatic of violence within society itself. The need for attention grows greater as the school year nears its close.
comments powered by Disqus
Robert Smith - 5/13/2006
"It can involve a thinking mode that causes them to see only one solution to their problems, an option that for a troubled child can become violent."
This is exactly correct. Kids who commit school shootings universally report being "trapped" and that the shooting was "the only way".
But the causes aren't really speculative. They stem from a combination of abuse and neglect. They're neglected (and/or abused) at home, and abused at school. This abuse is either ignored or, more often, encouraged by school officials. Eventually these kids come to see violence as the only solution to their problems.
"Such a thinking pattern can cause the child to see people as targets, especially if fueled by years of playing video games with violent themes."
Yeah, video games are the problem. Or maybe it's that demon rock n' roll music? Studies have consistently shown that this notion has no pasis in fact. Observing media does not cause violent behavior.
- Historian Daniel K. Williams says Democrats have a religion problem
- Bill O’Reilly – America’s best-selling “historian” – ridiculed in Harper’s for writing bad history
- Largest history festival is the UK criticized for being white and male
- Eric Foner doesn’t think much of a book that claims Lincoln moved slowly to emancipate blacks because he was a racist
- Harvard's Moshik Temkin pens op ed in the NYT warning historians not to use analogies