A Rocky Separation
tags: Steve Hochstadt,Israel,West Bank,Wall of Separation
I have never seen such a
rocky place as the West Bank. Among undulating hills and valleys, patches of
dirt are scattered among rocks of all sizes. A small field of plowed soil is a
rarity. For thousands of years, people have moved rocks so they could grow plants.
The steep hills have been cut horizontally with terraces dug by hand and animal
power. The terraces are supported by stone walls,
some looking relatively recent, some stretching back thousands of years. Some
of the olive orchards which line the layered earth look as old. These ancient
walls blend into the landscape and support an agricultural economy, a way of
life sustained by the people of this rocky land for thousands of years.
Recently a new type of wall
has appeared in the West Bank. Twenty feet high, sunk deep into the ground,
topped with barbed wire, the Israeli walls of separation prevent movement,
separate people and interrupt that very life.
The official political
separator between Israel and the occupied West Bank is the Green Line, drawn on
maps in 1949 to separate Israel from its neighbors at the end of a year’s
warfare. In the 1967 Six Day War, Israel occupied Palestinian territory beyond
the Green Line: East Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza. Nearly 50 years later,
the conflict over this land continues.
The major separation wall
generally follows the Green Line, but small and significant deviations reveal a
long-term Israeli population policy of separating themselves from Palestinians
and expanding their borders. The wall bulges out to encompass less inhabited
hills and valleys. It bulges in to exclude Palestinian villages and urban
settlements from the rest of Israel. It never actually crosses into Israeli territory,
only adding, but never subtracting land. Walls extend deep into the West Bank
to surround the many Israeli settlements that have been created there.
Every Israeli wall separates
Palestinians from their families, their friends, their customers, and their
culture. Shepherds are separated from grazing lands and water supply. Villages
are separated from one another. People are prevented from access to stores,
hospitals, government buildings, and each other.
Walls keep people out and
people in. From the Great Wall of China to more modern walls in Berlin and on
our border with Mexico, if walls are long enough, they can control entire
populations. Walls become security measures when the enemy is defined as
everyone on the other side.
Walls mean control and
control varies by the category of people. In 1977, I could negotiate the
annoying checkpoints in Berlin, cross the wall, and wander around a city that
no longer exists. East Berliners could only watch. Except the privileged ones,
whose greatest privilege was that they could go anywhere.
The new walls of Palestine
funnel all people through a network of gates, where privilege is doled out by
religion and nationality. We passed all the checkpoints with ease. Once a young
soldier bent over to talk to us in the back seat. Our role was to identify
ourselves as Americans, and she waved us on. Israelis, identified by their
license plates, drive through, barely slowing down. Cars with Palestinian
plates, and the much more numerous Palestinian walkers, are stopped. Some walls
are impenetrable: many roads in the West Bank have been built only for Israeli
settlers, connecting isolated enclaves back to Israel. Other walls are just
difficult. A delay of hours, plus humiliating treatment, must be part of every
Palestinian’s plan for negotiating a checkpoint.
These walls are part of a
larger scheme to shape the population of Jerusalem and the West Bank in Israeli
interests. The walls operate in conjunction with colored identification cards
to segregate Palestinians into exclusive categories. Those with blue cards are
considered to be residents of Jerusalem, and can move more freely than those
with green cards, “West Bankers”. Green card holders can enter Jerusalem, which
they have considered their capital for centuries, only with special permits.
The entire system of walls, identification cards and checkpoints makes travel
by Palestinians in the West Bank difficult and time-consuming.
The Israeli government is
worried about the demographic future. What does a state that proclaims itself
Jewish do with a Palestinian minority that threatens to grow? The wall is one
answer – exclude some, prevent others from entering, encourage them all to
Israel uses wall-building to
promote ethnic exclusion. Other more coercive methods are also being used to
reconstruct the population of the West Bank. In September 2014, new plans were
revealed which would move thousands of Bedouins away from their villages just east of Jerusalem into
one new “Bedouin township” miles north and east, near the border with Jordan. That
expulsion would clear a large area for future Israeli settlements. Protests by
Palestinians and some Israelis have interfered with these plans, which appear
to violate the Geneva Convention about treatment of an occupied population.
Even the privileged have to
submit to the power of the wall. We started on the ancient route from Jerusalem
to Jericho, just over 20 miles, cut thousands of years ago into a rolling
landscape of rocky slopes. But just outside of East Jerusalem, we ran into a wall,
towering over us, turning the road into a parking lot. Go away, the wall said.
Walls are bad for both sides. These walls will eventually fall, too, but not until they have harmed the lives of all the people of Palestine.
Jacksonville ILPublished in the Jacksonville Journal-Courier, February 3, 2015
comments powered by Disqus
- How the Gilded Age's Top 1 Percent Thrived on Corruption
- The return of Ken Starr: He pushed impeachment for Clinton but now defends Trump
- The first transport of Jews to Auschwitz was 997 teenage girls. Few survived.
- As India’s Constitution Turns 70, Opposing Sides Fight to Claim Its Author as One of Their Own
- "You shall never be a bystander." How We Learn About the Holocaust When the Last Survivors Are Gone
- What Happens When You Give Students Control of the Syllabus?
- A Civil War-era ‘witch bottle’ may have been found on a Virginia highway, archaeologists say
- The Future of the Academy at the Association of American Colleges and Universities
- The Way We Write History Has Changed
- Rethinking How We Train Historians