Blogs Cliopatria Larson on "Intelligent Design"
Aug 27, 2005Larson on "Intelligent Design"
Edward J. Larson,"A Natural Selection: Intelligent Design," LA Times, 26 August. The former fellow at the Discovery Institute and distinguished historian of the evolution controversy argues that"intelligent design" is not science. Key graphs:
Intelligent design, despite its proponents' claims to the contrary, isn't modern science. It's part of that rebellion against it. Scientists look for natural explanations for natural phenomena. Their best explanations, if they survive rigorous testing, become scientific theories.Thanks to Glenn Reynolds at Instapundit for the tip.
Intelligent design, in contrast, is a critique of all that. Its proponents may challenge the sufficiency of evolutionary explanations for the origin of species but they have not — and cannot — offer testable alternative explanations. The best they can offer is the premise that, if no natural explanation suffices, then God must have done it. Maybe God did do it, but if so, it's beyond science.
But, as Cosma Shalizi and Tim Burke have pointed out, from the point of view of traditional Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, a g_d who merely fills diminishing gaps in evolutionary theory as a causative explanation, is not the G_d of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, before whom there is no other. ID's g_d of the diminishing gaps is no longer one worthy of worship, but of pity for his increasing irrelevance.
comments powered by Disqus
News
- Health Researchers Show Segregation 100 Years Ago Harmed Black Health, and Effects Continue Today
- Understanding the Leading Thinkers of the New American Right
- Want to Understand the Internet? Consider the "Great Stink" of 1858 London
- As More Schools Ban "Maus," Art Spiegelman Fears Worse to Come
- PEN Condemns Censorship in Removal of Coates's Memoir from AP Course
- Should Medicine Discontinue Using Terminology Associated with Nazi Doctors?
- Michael Honey: Eig's MLK Bio Needed to Engage King's Belief in Labor Solidarity
- Blair L.M. Kelley Tells Black Working Class History Through Family
- Review: J.T. Roane Tells Black Philadelphia's History from the Margins
- Cash Reparations to Japanese Internees Helped Rebuild Autonomy and Dignity






