Watergate Scrapbook: What Do You Remember?History Q & A
Thirty years ago today spies hired by the Committee to Re-Elect the President broke into the Watergate headquarters of the Democratic National Committee and were caught.
- "I am not a crook."
- "There must be no whitewash at the White House."
- "One year of Watergate is enough."
- "How much money do you need?" Nixon asked. John Dean:"I would say these people are going to cost a million dollars over the next two years." Nixon:"We could get that ... you could get a million dollars. And you could get it in cash. I, I know where it could be gotten--" Dean:"Uh-uh." Nixon:"I mean, it's not easy but it could be done."
- "I want you all to stonewall it, let them plead the Fifth Amendment, cover-up, or anything else, if it'll save it, save the plan."
- "Play it rough. That's the way they're going to play it and that's the way we are going to play it."
- "I'll pardon the bastards."
- "What really hurts in matters of this sort is not the fact that they occur, because overzealous people in campaigns do things that are wrong,. What really hurts is if you try to cover it up."
- "The arts, you know, they're Jews, they're left wing. In other words, stay away."
- "Give 'em an hors d'oeuvre and maybe they won't come back for the main course."
- "You don't know how to lie," Nixon told a political associate."If you can't lie, you'll never go anywhere."
- [expletive deleted]
- "When the president does it, that means that it is not illegal."
- "Let us begin by committing ourselves to the truth, to see it like
it is and tell it like it is, to find the truth, to speak the truth and to
live the truth. That's what we will do." Acceptance Speech, 1968, Republican
- "How do you know that, Mr. Chairman?" asked John Ehrlichman at the Senate Watergate hearings."Because I can understand the English language. It's my mother's tongue."
- " When the going gets tough, the tough get going."
- "Katie Graham's gonna get her tit caught in a big fat wringer if that's published."
- Of FBI Director L. Patrick Gray:"Let him hang there; let him twist slowly, slowly in the wind."
- "There's a cancer on the presidency."
- "Once the toothpaste is out of the tube it's going to be very hard to get it back in."
- Ziegler: referring to the announcement that President Nixon believed no none in the administration,"past or present" should be given"immunity from prosecution," stated that this was"the operative statement." R. W. Apple, Jr. asked if that meant all other statements were"inoperative." Yes, responded Ziegler.
- "A third-rate burglary."
MYSTERIES OF WATERGATE
Who Was Deep Throat?
Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the Washington Post reporters who first broke the story of Watergate, have never identified their chief source, dubbed Deep Throat, after a pornographic movie of the same name. They promise to reveal his name after he dies. For 30 years it's been the best kept secret in Washington.
Many people have tried to guess the identity of Deep Throat.
- John Dean in an ebook published today on Salon.com identifies four likely suspects: Pat Buchanan, Ray Price, Steve Bull, Ron Ziegler. Last month a press release indicated that Dean had figured out who Deep Throat was and was prepared to name the person in his ebook. That person was apparently Nixon aide Jonathan Rose, a former Army intelligence officer, who attended Yale with Bob Woodward. But Rose threatened to sue and Dean backed off.
- Leonard Garment, Nixon's lawyer, claimed in a book last year, In Search of Deep Throat, that he had solved the riddle, naming John Sears.
- William Gaines, Knight Chair professor of investigative and enterprise reporting at the University of Illinois, assigned his classes to study all available evidence to determine Deep Throat's identity. After three years of research the students unanimously settled on Patrick Buchanan.
Did Nixon Know in Advance About the Watergate Break-in?
Nixon always maintained that he did not have advance knowledge of the break-in and no hard evidence has ever surfaced to indicate that he did. John Mitchell knew, as he admitted to Bob Haldeman. Both Alexander Butterfield and Leonard Garment believed Nixon knew. Butterfield said he'd stake his life on it.
Did Nixon Know in Advance About the Break-in at the Office of Daniel Ellsberg's Psychiatrist?
On June 13, 1971 the New York Times published the famous Pentagon Papers, a secret history of the Vietnam War initiated by LBJ Defense Secretary Robert McNamara. The papers were leaked to the Times by Daniel Ellsberg. At first, Nixon responded to the scoop with indifference; most of the disclosures were embarrassing to Democrats. But Henry Kissinger, his national security advisor, was furious and claimed it made the United States look weak. In September a White House-sponsored gang of thugs known as the Plumbers broke into the office of Ellsberg's psychiatrist, Dr. Fred Fielding, in hopes of finding dirt on Ellsberg. They failed.
Nixon always claimed that he did not know in advance about the break-in. Egil"Bud" Krogh, the White House official in charge of the Plumbers, told John Dean in March 1973 that the break-in was Nixon's idea. NIxon claimed he did not find out until Dean told him on March 17. But in his memoirs Nixon said that he would have been justified in ordering the break-in on the grounds of national security. As Nixon had famously said previously, if the president does it, it's not illegal.
GOOD AND BAD CONSEQUENCES OF WATERGATE
Investigative reporting (revived)
|Investigative reporting (carried too far)|
Nixon forced out of office
|Because of the scandal, the system favored the election of an outsider with no national experience (Jimmy Carter ) in 1976|
Imperial presidency trimmed back
|Pictures of the next president (Gerald Ford) fetching his own paper and toasting bagels became iconic|
|Americans, already traumatized by Vietnam, became ever more cynical|
Establishment of tradition of special prosecutors
|Establishment of tradition of special prosecutors|
Presidential papers put under the control of the archivist of the United States
|Presidential papers put under the control of the archivist of the United States (unless a subsequent president chooses to eviscerate the law with an executive order)|
FBI and CIA made independent of the White House
|FBI and CIA fearful of conducting aggressive investigations (in part a consequence of Church Committee hearings)|
OFFENSES OF WATERGATE
More than 70 people were convicted of crimes related to Watergate (some pleaded guilty before trial). Attorney General John Mitchell, referring to the crimes committed by officials, called them the White House Horrors.
- Breaking into Ellsberg's psychiatrist's office.
- Mitchell gave approval to the break-in at the Watergate.
- G. Gordon Liddy proposed firebombing the Brookings Institution.
- E. Howard Hunt fabricated documents implicating John Kennedy in the assassination of South Vietnamese President Diem.
- John Ehrlichman ordered FBI Director Gray to take possession of the files in Hunt's safe, keeping them secret from prosecutors.
- Gray destroyed the evidence from Hunt's safe.
- Henry Petersen gave Dean secret grand jury testimony.
- Gray at the FBI gave Dean access to all FBI investigation files.
- Creation of the Plumbers at the White House to plug leaks through the use of illegal wiretaps.
- Sandwedge: The Caulfield operation designed to orchestrate a massive campaign to spy on the Democrats.
- Ehrlichman claimed he did not know in advance about the Ellsberg break-in; he knew.
- Gemstone: The Liddy operation to kidnap students who might disrupt the Republican convention in 1972; use prostitutes to compromise Democratic politicians. Attorney General Mitchell objected to the plan on the grounds it cost too much; he later approved a scaled-down plan. Mitchell, Haldeman and Jeb Magruder approved of Gemstone.
- Hush money paid to Watergate break-in defendants.
- Nixon promised clemency to Watergate criminals.
- Caulfield sent to Chappequiddick to pose as a reporter to dig up dirt on Kennedy before all the leaks.
- Nixon is heard on the tapes telling Ehrlichman in April 1973 that he should hint to Dean to stay on the reservation because in the end the only man who can grant Dean clemency and save his ability to practice law is the president.
- Charles Colson was guilty of offering clemency to Hunt at Nixon's orders.
- Nixon told Petersen to stay out of the Ellsberg psychiatrist's break-in on the grounds that an investigation would compromise national security.
- Nixon proposed to Alexander Haig and Fred Buzhardt that they manufacture evidence -- a missing dictabelt tape -- wanted by Judge John Sirica; both refused.
- Nixon ordered the IRS to audit the tax returns of Larry O'Brien, head of the Democratic National Committee.
- Nixon ordered the IRS to stop an investigation of Howard Hughes.
- Huston Plan: In June 1970 Tom Huston persuaded the heads of the CIA, DIA, and NSA to approve a plan for black bag jobs against"enemies" of the Nixon administration. (J. Edgar Hoover opposed the Huston Plan; Nixon, fearful Hoover would blackmail him by leaking word of the plan, dropped it.)
comments powered by Disqus
Timothy William Mason - 9/19/2004
Ok here goes, I hitchhiki from home in Iowa that Summer while in college to Washington DC area stay the weekend w/ two girls from hometown who are young clerks for the FBI. Sunday afternoon late they give me a ride into the city and drop me off at the Old Senate Office Building. I walk up to the entrance and ask a couple of federal uniformed security cops if this is the entrance to the Watergate Hearings and they laugh and say "Yes". I set down my backpack and say good,i'm gonna sit in in the morning.They laugh again and say just beacause you are the first here does not mean you will be one of the 200 ndred members of the public in. They expalin it is chaos and unruly. I being a 24 year old say we will see about that. I borrow a piece of legal paper and a pen from the officers and number 200 hundred individual little block "tickets" and tear out number one and put it in my pocket and set up my "bunk on the top step. As nighttime comes folks begin to show up and I explain what we are gonna do and I start to tear and assighn tickets. A very defined straight line is formed down the steps and down the sidewalk. We are even so condfident some of us leave and go get pizza from collected money. The next morning, I believe 9 am I'm the first member of the public to enter the hearnings and the next 199 who had the little tickets enter behind. The day shift guards remarked thay had never seen it so quiet and orgainized that Summer. L. Patrick Gray was on the stand that day and I remember it was a very interesting day and all the major players were there. THank you
Sara - 1/6/2004
The PBS documentary series on Watergate claims Colson proposed firebombing the Brookings Institute.
Warren F. Kelleyt - 11/13/2003
Shirley, I have no immediate comment about "Deep Throat", but I would like to talk with you about "Watergate" if you have the time.
The fact that Magruder came forward to point the finger at Nixom revived my interest in the matter.
Warren F. Kelley
Shirley Shorter - 8/11/2003
THE NEWS IS OUT
What do we know about Deep Throat?
He was a Federal Prosecutor in the Justice Department, Assistant to Chief Judge Sirica during Watergate.
This Scotch-drinking Jesuit-trained lawyer was the Court’s liaison to the FBI and CIA, a former spy, an expert in conspiracy law.
He has become a modern legend, a template for Hollywood characters, the G-Man in the parking garage, the smoking man in a trenchcoat.
Joseph Lowther is the man with the deep voice, the mysterious informant who helped bring down a President ...
"...Yes, Lowther had informed to him but he was only a third or fourth degree informant" - Bob Woodward
Article by Fraser Smith, In Search Of Deep Throat, Regardie's, July - August, 1994
"I held back on them...because I didn't trust the dear boys".
- Joseph Lowther, in an interview about his meetings with Woodward and Bernstein
“Served as counter intelligence officer in apprehension and investigation of enemy agents. Also general security and counter sabotage.”
- From Lowther’s Army Separation Qualification Record
“He was a better debater than Ed Williams”
- Robert Maheu, CEO to Howard Hughes during the Nixon Administration, former classmate of Lowther’s
“... my congratulations on the outstanding presentation of the Government’s case you made... with the prosecution of the Communist Party, USA”
- J. Edgar Hoover, letter to Lowther, November 22, 1965
“My most fruitful source, whose identity I cannot reveal, was not at the FBI but elsewhere in the Justice Department where the fear was rampant that Nixon would shut down the Watergate investigation...”
- Jack Anderson, Columnist, from his book Peace, War and Politics (1999; page 249)
"Bernstein tried thinking as Woodward would. What did he have? ...There was no evidence, beyond a Justice Department lawyer's angry reactions."
- Bernstein, Carl, and Bob Woodward, in their book All the President’s Men (1974; page 129).
Scott Fe - 4/23/2003
Daniel Ellsberg's PSYCHIATRIST was Dr. Lewis Fielding, NOT Fred Fielding, as mis-tated above.
Tony Cantu - 9/9/2002
I thought it was Colson who had proposed firebombing the Brookings Institution. In the list of offenses related to Watergate, it indicates Liddy had proposed this notion.
- Rubio Surges Into Second In New Hampshire
- Branstad Says Cruz Ran ‘Unethical’ Campaign
- Christie Highlights Santorum’s Endorsement of Rubio
- Portman Comes Out Against Trade Deal
- Megyn Kelly Gets a Book Deal
- A Big List of the Bad Things Clinton Has Done
- An Unambiguous Sign Sanders Won Last Night’s Debate
- Still Friends at the End
- Quote of the Day
- Trump Still Leads as Clinton Slips
- Clinton Can’t Shake Image as Wall Street’s Friend
- Maddow Doesn’t See Sanders Winning
- Why Does the Media Still Shield Chelsea Clinton?
- Bush Jokes His Mother May Have Abused Him
- Rubio Closes the Gap in New Hampshire
- Newly released interactive map shows images of destroyed monuments of Mosul
- How the Rise of the Post Office Explains American Innovation
- These Americans are reliving history and don’t mind repeating it
- Britain largest home is saved for the nation
- Shelter and the slums: capturing bleak Britain 50 years ago
- WSJ features an article by a conservative calling for the abolition of Black History Month
- Mary Beard, herself a bestselling author, wonders why more women historians aren't
- Princeton U. historian Imani Perry claims mistreatment in parking ticket arrest
- Retired historian George Dennison remains on the payroll at the U. of Montana while faculty are cut
- The Atlantic profiles exciting ways to teach history