IBM: And that’s How the Trains Ran on Time
Recently discovered Nazi documents and Polish eyewitness testimony make clear that IBM's alliance with the Third Reich went far beyond its German subsidiary. During the Rape of Poland and the Polish Holocaust, which killed millions and plundered a nation, IBM technology was a key factor. That custom-tailored technology was provided not through the German subsidiary, but directly through a new special Polish subsidiary reporting to IBM New York, mainly at its headquarters at 590 N. Madison in Manhattan.
And that's how the trains ran on time to Auschwitz.
GOOD NEWS FOR IBM
Watson learned early on that a government in reorganization, and indeed a government tightly monitoring its society, was good news for IBM. More forms, more reports, more registrations, more statistics-IBM thrived on red tape.
In 1933, the Third Reich offered Watson the opportunity to cater to intense Nazi government control, supervision, surveillance, and regimentation on a plane never before known. The fact that Hitler planned to extend his Reich to other nations only magnified the prospective profits. The technology was almost exclusively IBM's to purvey because the firm controlled about 90 percent of the world market in punch cards and sorters.
As for the moral dilemma, it simply did not exist for IBM. Supplying the Nazis with the customized technology and joint-planning they needed was not even debated. In thousands of IBM-related documents that have been reviewed, there were vigorous and on-going efforts to preserve IBM's monopoly in the Nazi market, exclude competitors and increase contracts to meet sales quotas. But not a single sentence has been uncovered questioning the morality of automating the Third Reich or pausing the relationship even as headlines proclaimed the mass murder of Jews.
Just after Hitler assumed power, Nazi Germany quickly became IBM's most valuable client outside the U.S. IBM's German subsidiary was Deutsche Hollerith Maschinen Gesellschaft, known by the acronym, Dehomag. Watson tightly managed the lucrative German operations. Watson traveled to Berlin at least twice annually from 1933 until 1939 to personally supervise Dehomag. When German managers wanted to paint a corridor, they awaited his specific permission. All major German correspondence was translated for review by the New York Office, Watson himself often personally reading the material. Before major new accounts were accepted, Watson had to assent. He insisted on making direct verbal instructions to his German managers the rule rather than exception--even in place of major agreements. Not infrequently Dehomag managers objected to his"domination," especially since the branch's by-laws gave him a personal veto over any action by the German subsidiary. Watson's auditors continuously tracked the source and status of every mark and pfennig--in one typical case exchanging numerous trans-Atlantic letters over the disposition of just a few dollars. Understandably, IBM's lawyers and managers in Berlin personally updated Watson constantly, and generally signed their reports,"Awaiting your further instructions."
No machines were sold--only leased. IBM was the sole source of all punch cards, and spare parts, and serviced the machines on site either directly or through its authorized dealer network or other field trainees. There were no universal punch cards. Each series was custom-designed by IBM engineers not only to capture the information going in, but also to tabulate the information the Nazis wanted to come out. For example, one series of punch cards was designed not only to record religion, national origin and mother tongue, but also special categories including: Jew, Polish language, Polish nationality, the fur trade as an occupation, and Berlin. Nazis could quickly cross-tabulate exactly how many Berlin furriers were Jews of Polish extraction. Railroad cars, which could take two weeks to locate and route, could be swiftly dispatched in just 48 hours by means of a vast network of punch card machines. IBM services coursed through the entire German infrastructure throughout Europe.
World War II broke out on September 1, 1939 when Germany invaded Poland. Germany annexed northwestern Poland. The remaining Polish territory was treated as"occupied" and called the"General Government." That northwestern quadrant was serviced by IBM's German subsidiary, Dehomag. In annexed Poland, Dehomag mainly serviced the payroll of Silesian coal mines and heavy industry.
WATSON BUSINESS MACHINES
At about that time, IBM NY established a special new subsidiary, totally separate and apart from its German subsidiary. IBM's new Polish company was called Watson Business Machines. Its sole purpose was to service the Nazi occupation during the rape of Poland. The Polish subsidiary was also known to the Nazis as Watson Büromaschinen, the German equivalent of Watson Business Machines. The enterprise would require dozens of custom-wired punch card machines, and millions of proprietary punch cards especially designed and printed for each application. At the time, it was still completely legal for IBM to service the Third Reich--and it remained legal until just before America entered the war in December 1941.
The rape of Poland was no secret to IBM executives. From the outset, worldwide headlines reported barbarous massacres, rapes, inflicted starvation, systematic deportations, and the resulting unchecked epidemics. As early as September 13, 1939, the New York Times reported the Reich's determination to make Polish Jewry disappear with a headline declaring,"Nazis Hint Purge of Jews in Poland." A subhead declared:"3,000,000 Population Involved." The article quoted the German government's plan for the"removal of the Polish Jewish population from the European domain." The Times then added,"How … the 'removal' of Jews from Poland [can be achieved] without their extermination … is not explained."
But Germany had plans. Polish Jews, during a sequence of sudden relocations, were to be catalogued for further action in a massive cascade of repetitive censuses and registrations with up-to-date information being instantly available to various Nazi planning agencies and occupation offices. How much usable forced labor for armament factories and useful skills could they generate? How many thousands would die from month to month under the new starvation regimen? A spectrum of Nazi census, registration and statistical tabulation was performed on custom-made IBM punch card programs and machinery.
At first, IBM's involvement with the rape of Poland was managed through its German subsidiary, Dehomag. On September 9, 1939, Dehomag general manager Hermann Rottke wrote directly to Watson in New York asking for advanced alphabetizers. He reminded him,
During your last visit in Berlin at the beginning of July, you made the kind offer to me that you might be willing to furnish the German company machines from Endicott [New York] in order to shorten our long delivery terms . . .You have complied with this request, for which I thank you very much, and have added that in cases of urgent need, I may make use of other American machines . . .
You will understand that under today's conditions, a certain need has arisen for such machines, which we do not build as yet in Germany. Therefore, I should like to make use of your kind offer and ask you to leave with the German company . . . the alphabetic tabulating machines …
On September 28, 1939, the day after a vanquished Warsaw formally capitulated, IBM's European general manager in Geneva, J. W. Schotte, telephoned Berlin to confirm Watson's permission. Company notes record the"friendly spirit" of the call.
Meanwhile, Reinhard Heydrich, Chief of Himmler's Security Service, the SD, circulated a top secret Express Letter to the chiefs of his murderous Einsatzgruppen, operating in the occupied territories. Heydrich's September 21, 1939 memo was captioned:"The Jewish Question in the Occupied Territory." It began,"I would like to point out once more that the total measures planned, (i.e., the final aim) are to be kept strictly secret."
The first step, the memo explained, was population control through a sequence of strategic censuses and registrations. First, Jews were to be relocated to so-called concentration towns which are"either at railroad junctions or at least lie on a railway." Addressing the zone covered by Einsatzgruppe I, from east of Krakow to the former Slovak-Polish border, Heydrich directed,"Within this territory, only a temporary census of Jews need be taken."
Heydrich demanded that"the chiefs of the Einsatzgruppen report to me continually regarding … the census of Jews in their districts.…"
Shortly thereafter, Heydrich sent a follow-up cable to his occupying forces in Poland, Upper Silesia, and Czechoslovakia. This cable outlined how a new census scheduled for December 17, 1939 would escalate the process from mere identification and cataloging to deportation and execution as people were rapidly moved into Polish ghettos to await the next step.
Heydrich's memo, entitled,"Evacuation of the New Eastern Provinces," decreed:
the evacuation of Poles and Jews in the new Eastern Provinces will be conducted by the Security Police … The census documents provide the basis for the evacuation. All persons in the new provinces possess a copy. The census form is the temporary identification card giving permission to stay. Therefore, all persons have to hand over the card before deportation. . . . anyone caught without this card is subject to possible execution.… It is projected that the census will take place on December 17, 1939."How long would it take to quantify and organize the deportation of millions from various regions across Eastern Europe? Using paper and pencil could take years. Relying upon the lightning speed of Hollerith machines, it took just days. Nazi Germany employed only one method for conducting a census: IBM punch cards processes, each one custom-designed to the specific census.
NEW YORK'S CONTROL OF THE MACHINES
IBM's involvement in Nazi-occupied Poland continued, but now through a special New York-controlled subsidiary known as Watson Business Machines, newly headquartered at Kreuz 23 in Warsaw.
An important Watson Business Machines customer site, newly discovered, was the Hollerith Department of Polish Railways, located at 22 Pawia Street in Krakow. This office kept tabs on all trains in the General Government, including those which sent Jews to their death in Treblinka and Auschwitz. Leon Krzemieniecki is probably the only man still living who worked in that Hollerith Department. It must be emphasized that Krzemieniecki did not understand any of the details of the genocidal train destinations. Indeed his duties required tabulating information on all trains, from ordinary passenger to freight trains. The high-security five-room office, guarded by armed railway police, was equipped with fifteen punchers, two sorters, and a tabulator"bigger than a sofa."
Fifteen Polish women punched the cards and loaded the sorters. Three German nationals supervised the office, overseeing the final tabulations and summary statistics in great secrecy. Handfuls of print-outs were reduced to a small envelope of summary data, which was then delivered to a secret destination. Truckloads of the preliminary printouts were then regularly burned, along with the spent cards, Krzemieniecki recalls.
As a forced laborer, Krzemieniecki was compelled to work as a"sorter and tabulator" ten hours per day for two years. He never realized in any way that his work involved the transportation of Jews to gas chambers."I only know that this very modern equipment made possible the control of all the railway traffic in the General Government," he has said.
Krzemieniecki recounts that an"outside technician," who spoke German and Polish and"did not work for the railroad," was almost constantly on site to keep the machines running. The technician generally undertook major maintenance on the machines approximately once each month.
IBM spokesman Carol Makovich in New York repeated the same official statement she issued more than a year ago:"IBM does not have much information about this period."
IBM's tailored railroad management programs, several million custom-designed punch cards printed at IBM's 6 Rymarska print shop across from the Warsaw Ghetto, and the railway's leased machines were not under the German subsidiary, but the New York-controlled subsidiary in Warsaw. The distinction is important. Since the disclosures about IBM's involvement in the Holocaust first surfaced in February 2001, the company has continually pointed to supposed lack of control of its German subsidiary. But Watson Business Machines was established in Poland by IBM New York after the Nazi invasion to profitably service the Reich's plunder and ethnic cleansing programs.
"I knew they were not German machines," recalled Krzemieniecki."The labels were in English… The person maintaining and repairing the machines spread the diagrams out sometimes. The language of the diagrams of those machines was only in English."
I asked Krzemieniecki if the machine logo plates were in German, Polish, or English. He answered"English. It said 'Business Machines.'" I asked,"Do you mean, 'International Business Machines?'" Krzemieniecki replied,"No, 'Watson Business Machines.'" That was the correct answer. In Poland, IBM NY's new subsidiary operated under the German legal name: Watson Büromaschinen. But the Polish machines proudly bore logo tags with the subsidiary's name in English: Watson Business Machines. Watson created several IBM subsidiaries named after himself, each one strictly confined to one national territory. Watson Belge was the Belgian subsidiary. Watson Italiana served as the Italian company. In Sweden, it was Svenska Watson. In many places, the business names Watson and IBM were synonymous and inseparable.
Dwarfing the railroad operation in Poland was the massive Hollerith statistical center at 24 Murnerstrasse in Kraków, staffed by more than 500 punching and tabulating employees and dozens of machines. New research has discovered a previously unknown Berlin agency, the Central Office for Foreign Statistics and Foreign Country Research, which continuously received detailed data from the Statistics Office in Kraków. New discoveries about this office answer questions about where much of the data for all of Poland was processed.
Hollerith-equipped Nazi offices had been operating across occupied Poland from the day of invasion on September 1, 1939. America was not in the war. Hence, IBM maintained its complete commercial support for the Hitler regime throughout the initial rape of Poland. As part of this strategic commercial support, IBM NY agreed to an installation of Nazi statistical machines so massive it was not called a Hollerith Department, but a Hollerith Gruppe. This vital installation would permit the Nazis to organize the systematic looting and subjugation of Poland, as well as implement other plans for Polish citizens.
THE WIZARD OF STATISTICS
By November 2, 1939, the Reich's Jewish-population statistics wizard, Fritz Arlt, had been appointed head of the Population and Welfare Administration of the"General Government." Arlt, a Hollerith expert and a colleague of Eichmann, edited his own statistical publication, Political Information Service of the General Government. The publication featured such detailed data as Jewish population per square meter with sliding projections of decrease resulting from such imposed conditions as forced labor and starvation. One Arlt article asserted,"We can count on the mortality of some subjugated groups. These include babies and those over the age of 65, as well as those who are basically weak and ill in all other age groups."
Quickly, the data-hungry Nazis ordered a Central Statistics Office established in Kraków. By April 1940, the Nazis formed a working group comprised of a single German statistics expert assisted by former employees of the Polish Statistical Service. This group, along with all previously supplied Hollerith machines and staff, were relocated from Warsaw to the new Nazi agency in Kraków.
By September 1940, the Reich issued a Decree for Statistics in Poland, creating the new expanded"Statistics Office." Within a few months, the Kraków Statistics Office at 24 Murnerstrasse subsumed most other statistical operations in Poland. The Statistics Office was divided into six distinct groups-Group I: Administration; Group II: Population and Culture; Group III: Food and Agriculture; Group IV: Economic Trade and Transportation; Group V: Social Statistics; and Group VI: Finance and Tax. A November 30, 1941, Statistics Office report explains:"The Hollerith Gruppe area of operation stretches across all subject areas," adding that a major expansion plan would see staffing rise to 500 persons within a month.
The expansion was dependent on more leased machines, spare parts, company technicians, and a continued, guaranteed supply of millions of additional IBM cards. Because backlogged orders for Hollerith machines required a year or more to deliver, IBM's long-term supply commitment almost certainly dated to the first days of World War II. Indeed, that November 30, 1941 Statistics Office report was written just weeks after IBM's European general manager, Werner Lier, visited Berlin in early October 1941 to oversee IBM NY's deployment of machines in Poland and other countries. In two detailed reports about European operations, written from Berlin and sent to Watson personally as well as the senior staff in New York, Lier reported moving a small group of Polish machines into Romania for the Jewish census there. But other Holleriths took their place.
That Kraków Statistics Office's November 30, 1941 report assured Berlin:"the installation of the equipment necessary for the work of the Hollerith Gruppe has commenced. It is estimated that the equipment will be ready for use by the end of the year, and that training of the prospective employees can begin."
The Statistics Office also assured Berlin that its Hollerith Gruppe would employ equipment more modern than the old IBM machinery found in most pre-war Polish data agencies, thus allowing the Nazi office to launch a plethora of"large-scale censuses." Everything would be counted--and often."The most important and complex census, the population and occupational census, has been in preparation since the beginning of the year," the report specified.
In addition to special censuses, the report enumerated a long list of" continuous statistical surveys," including those for population, domestic migration, infectious disease, and causes of death. Moreover, regular food and agriculture surveys were" coupled with summary surveys of the population and ethnic groups." Tabulating food supplies against ethnic numbers allowed the Nazis to ration caloric intake as they subjected the Jewish community to progressive starvation.
The Statistics Office's November 30, 1941 report concluded with the statement,"Our work is just beginning to bear fruit."
HOW IBM CONTINUED EARNING PROFITS AFTER PEARL HARBOR
Once the U.S. entered the war after December 10, 1941, the Reich appointed Hermann Fellinger, a Nazi devoted to IBM, as enemy property custodian. He maintained the original staff and managers, keeping Watson Business Machines productive for the Reich, and profitable for IBM NY. The Polish subsidiary continued to operate efficiently, but now reported to IBM's Geneva office, and from there to New York. The company was not looted, its leased machines were not seized. So-called"royalties" were remitted to IBM through Geneva. Lease payments and profits were preserved in special accounts. After the war, IBM recovered all its Polish profits and machines.
Contacted about IBM's Polish subsidiary's involvement in the Polish Holocaust, IBM spokesman Carol Makovich in New York repeated the same official statement she issued more than a year ago:"IBM does not have much information about this period." No matter how many times asked, Makovich simply repeated the phrase. That phrase is the key assertion of IBM's six-paragraph sole statement on the topic, asserting total lack of information, issued more than a year ago and still on its website. Makovich's obfuscation is in line with IBM's long history since World War II of obstructing or otherwise not cooperating with virtually every major independent author writing about its history, according to numerous published introductions, prefaces and acknowledgements.
But 21st century silence cannot alter the historical documentation. A tangle of subsidiaries throughout Europe helped IBM reap the benefits of its partnership with Nazi Germany. It was never about the anti-Semitism, never about Nazism. It was always about the money. As far as IBM was concerned,"business" was its middle name.
About the graphic on the homepage: Hundreds of thousands of concentration camp prisoners across Europe were registered with standard pre-printed paper Inmate Cards, called Haftlingkartei, approved by IBM to be compatible for its punch card process. IBM control markings are shown.
Copyright Edwin Black 2002
comments powered by Disqus
Kim - 10/30/2003
Does anyone know where this article was originally published?
Lee - 4/30/2003
I do not in any way condone the actions of the Nazis and the German people during World War 2, but why is it, some 60 years on, the Jews still try to bring as much attention to their plight as possible and look to people to blame. Get over it, those responsible are dead, nothing like this is ever going to happen again! Instead of trying to acuse of various peoples for their persecution of the Jewish people, look at why they have and do, the Jews have been responsible or been involved in more that the worlds share of conflicts throughout history. Get out of Palestine now, it's not your land. Thank yourself lucky that Hitler wasn't able to achieve his aim.
Look to the future and not the past, or you will always be resented by future generations.
Duby Diggs - 4/5/2002
A book entitled "IBM and the ethics of dealing with Nazi Germany, 1933-1941" could say much about a bottom line fixation of a greedy corporation. A book about the World War Two Holocaust needs to cover the time period which made that Holocaust The Holocaust. I haven't had time to read the book, but the excerpt presented here cuts off the story just as it reaches the most critical stage.
Ann Jefferson - 4/5/2002
So Mr. Diggs would argue that IBM's commitment to its bottom line rather than anything that we could recognize as ethics regarding fellow members of our species doesn't matter until 1942? If Black's information is accurate, and it gives every indication of being so, this work lends credence to the argument that is being heard with increasing frequency: the current corporate-directed globalization is nothing new, it's just losing its shock value. Let's hear it for a profit-driven world, and who cares if our fellows pay with their lives? After all, we have to deal with overpopulation somehow, and "Third World debt" is the new Final Solution.
edwinblack - 3/29/2002
The crucial time for the Final Solution is the 1942-1945. But the entire 12-year Holocaust followed six phases: Identification, Exclusion, Confiscation, Ghettoization, Deportation and Extermination. The Final Solution was the final and genocidal phase--but not the only phase. Therefore there were many crucial moments--to many to chronicle without a museum or encyclopedia. BTW, I am answering here, but I will ask readers to forgive me if I cannot get into a running dialog. That said, good holiday to all--edwin.
Duby Diggs - 3/29/2002
To answer the basic questions - what did they know, when did they know it and what did they then do ? - the crucial time frame begins in 1942 when "final solution" decisions were made and camps such as Auschwitz became centers for massive, coordinated, and systematic extermination. Unfortunately all but the last three paragraphs of this lengthy excerpt concern actions and activities before 1942, so we still do not "have much information about this period".
- 150 years later, schools are still a battlefield for interpreting Civil War
- Where are America's memorials to pain of slavery, black resistance?
- Richmond split over Confederate history
- The World's Jewish Population Is Nearing Pre-Holocaust Levels
- Bernie Sanders’s Revolutionary Roots Were Nurtured in ’60s Vermont
- Did a historian who said he’s a victim of McCarthyism get the story wrong?
- Stephanie Coontz’s work on the history of marriage cited by the Supreme Court.
- NYT History Book Reviews: Who Got Noticed this Week?
- David Hackett Fischer wins $100,000 prize for lifetime achievement in military writing