Are Muslim Extremists Really Upset About the Crusades?Roundup: Historians' Take
From an exchange on Richard Jensen's CNET list:
Matthew Richer (5-14-04)
The origins of conflicts are difficult to date, for sure. Some argue that our present conflict stems from the founding of Israel, others from our support for the Shah of Iran.
But does anyone seriously believe that Muslims knocked down the Twin Towers solely because of a grudge over Crusades?
Daniel Crandall (5-14-04)
Zuheir Abdallah, a columnist for the London-based Arabic daily Al-Hayat, wrote
the following in a recent commentary,
"Most Arabs hate the West, especially the U.S., for many reasons; some
date back to the Crusades and the Andalusia period, and more recently, because
of Palestine and Iraq."
In an article titled 'Nine Hundred Years and Two Crusades' published in late 1999, Dr. 'Azzam Al-Tamimi predicts that the Zionist enterprise will last 88 years, just like the Crusader invasion: "On the morning of Friday, 23 Sha'ban 492 H (July 15, 1099 C.E.), Jerusalem was raped by an estimated 1 million Crusaders who came all the way from Europe to allegedly liberate local Christians from Islamic oppression. Jerusalem was consequently turned into a blood pool. Between 60,000 and 70,000 Muslims and Jews were butchered. This was the ultimate conquest of a trail of blood that extended for thousands of miles. Nine hundred years later, Jerusalem finds itself once again in bondage. The invading crusade this time does not hoist the cross but rather the Star of David. The similarities are striking. Both campaigns originated in Europe, both used religion to justify aggression and butchery, and both were in essence motivated by purely mundane (secular) rather than religious considerations. In both cases, too, it was the weakness and disunity of the Muslims that contributed to the success of the invaders... In some ways, the 12th century awakening resembles today's Islamic awakening. In some other ways, the liberation of Jerusalem after 88 years of European occupation promises an imminent end to modern-day Zionist occupation of the first Qiblah [direction of prayer - i.e. Jerusalem]. In less than 40 years from now, this vision may just prove to be true."
Source: Palestine Times, August 1999, Dr. 'Azzam Al-Tamimi, 'Nine Hundred
Years and Two Crusades.'
20, 2003, as U.S. forces launched attacks on Saddam's regime, Al-Azhar University's
Islamic Research Complex called upon all Muslims to launch a Jihad in response
to the U.S. actions: "Jihad is an individual duty for all Muslims if the
U.S. launches a war against Iraq. Arabs and Muslims should be on high alert
to defend themselves, their doctrine and lands. [Muslims] have to forget all
internal differences so as not to surrender to prospective attacks. Jihad is
an individual duty in case an enemy occupies Muslims' lands. Our Arab and Muslim
nation will face new crusades that aim to deprive us of our homeland, doctrine
I can't resist providing another example of how the Crusades still dominate the lives of many Muslims. This is a portion of one of the Friday sermons delivered in the main mosques of Saudi Arabia. These are available on the Saudi-based website www.alminbar.net. Notice how the Sheikh paints a straight line from the Crusades to Bosnia-Herzegovina.
In the Mecca mosque, Sheikh Adnan Ahmad Siyami said, regarding International initiatives aimed at promoting interreligious harmony, "The Pope's recent visit to Syria, to the Al-Umawi mosque is, without a doubt, another manifestation of that call. The call by [the Pope] - may Allah punish him as he deserves - to the people of the [different] religions in Syria to live in peaceful coexistence is nothing more than an audacious call for the unification of religions, in accordance with the principle of human religious harmony. This Pope, the head of the Catholic Church, and those behind him calling for the unification of the religions, are the descendants of the Spanish inquisitors who tortured the Muslims most abominably. They are the descendants of those who led the Crusades to the Islamic East, in which thousands of Muslims were killed and their wives taken captive in uncountable numbers. They are the perpetrators of the massacres in Bosnia-Herzegovina. in Kosovo, in Indonesia, and in Chechnya. Can we expect compassion from these murderous wolves? What made the Pope go on his visit was his dissatisfaction with the robbing of the Muslims' lands; he wanted also to rob their religion, so that they lose both this world and the Hereafter."
Again this is from the MEMRI
comments powered by Disqus
- Marine Corps investigating photo of iconic flag-raising on Iwo Jima
- Scholars Blast New Study Tracing Ashkenazi Jews to Khazars of Ancient Turkey
- Legendary Explorer’s Long-Lost Ship May Have Been Found Off Rhode Island
- More Doubts, Opposition To Sale Of Unique, Hartford Collection Of Political History
- How the Curse of Sykes-Picot Still Haunts the Middle East
- The Historian Whitewashing Ukraine’s Past
- Andrew Roberts wins $250,000 prize from the conservative Bradley Foundation
- Daniel Aaron, Critic and Historian Who Pioneered American Studies, Dies at 103
- Liz Covart's amazingly popular podcast helps her audience understand early American history
- Justus Rosenberg is still teaching at age 95