How Many Contested Conventions Have There Been?Google Questions
tags: election 2016, contested convention
Attendees at the 1952 convention
The growing possibility of a contested Republican Party convention in July draws more interest in examining the history of contested party conventions, as to whether it is common or unusual. The clear cut conclusion is that they are more the norm historically, if not recently.
Ten Republican conventions, fifteen Democratic conventions, and three Whig conventions between 1840 and 1952, went to multiple ballots, with only thirteen of the nominees winning the Presidency, and the other fifteen nominees losing the White House. It should be pointed out that the Democratic Party had more contested conventions due to the two thirds rule that was in effect from the first Democratic National Convention in 1832 until 1936, so only Adlai Stevenson in 1952 did not have to face this difficult challenge on percentage of delegates, that the Whigs and Republicans never had to deal with.
Nineteen of these twenty eight contested conventions occurred in the 19th century, between 1840 and 1896, a very tumultuous and divided time in American politics, where Presidential elections were often very close. Three Whig Party nominees had contested nomination battles over twelve years, including William Henry Harrison in 1840; Zachary Taylor in 1848; and Winfield Scott in 1852, with Scott the only loser of the Presidency. We see six Republican nominees having to fight for the Presidential nomination over 32 years, including John C. Fremont in 1856; Abraham Lincoln in 1860; Rutherford B. Hayes in 1876; James A. Garfield in 1880; James G. Blaine in 1884; and Benjamin Harrison in 1888, all winning except for Fremont and Blaine.
At the same time, we have ten Democratic nominees engaged in battles for the nomination of their party over 52 years, including James K. Polk in 1844; Lewis Cass in 1848; Franklin Pierce in 1852; James Buchanan in 1856; Stephen Douglas in 1860; Horatio Seymour in 1868; Samuel Tilden in 1876; Winfield Scott Hancock in 1880; Grover Cleveland in 1884; and William Jennings Bryan in 1896, with Polk, Pierce, Buchanan and Cleveland occupying the White House.
Then from 1912 to 1952, another nine contested conventions occurred with multiple ballots, and we see four Republican nominees having a struggle for the nomination of their party, including Charles Evans Hughes in 1916; Warren G. Harding in 1920; Wendell Willkie in 1940; and Thomas E. Dewey in 1948, with only Harding winning the Presidency. Meanwhile, five Democratic nominees fought for their party’s nomination, including Woodrow Wilson in 1912; James Cox in 1920; John W. Davis in 1924; Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932; and Adlai Stevenson in 1952, with only Wilson and FDR winning the Presidency.
So the thirteen nominees in contested conventions who won the Presidency were William Henry Harrison in 1840; James K. Polk in 1844; Zachary Taylor in 1848; Franklin Pierce in 1852; James Buchanan in 1856; Abraham Lincoln in 1860; Rutherford B. Hayes in 1876; James A. Garfield in 1880; Grover Cleveland in 1884; Benjamin Harrison in 1888; Woodrow Wilson in 1912; Warren G. Harding in 1920; and Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932. Therefore, two Whigs, five Republicans, and six Democrats were elevated to the White House. The fifteen losing candidates included one Whig, five Republicans, and nine Democrats.
Twenty national elections in total faced a contested convention without a nominee on the first ballot in the 112 years between 1840 and 1952, a total of 29 elections, or slightly more than two thirds of the time! Both parties had multiple ballots to select nominees in 1848, 1852, 1856, and 1860, before the Civil War; 1876, 1880, and 1884 during the Gilded Age; and in 1920. In twelve of the fifteen national elections between 1840 and 1896, all but three (1864, 1872, and 1892), faced contested conventions. Then from 1912 to 1952, over eleven election cycles, all but three (1928, 1936 and 1944) were years of contested conventions. Interestingly, in the three election years of 1900 to 1908, three consecutive election cycles, contested conventions were avoided.
The contested conventions with the most ballots required were the 1924 Democratic convention which took 103 ballots to nominate John W. Davis; the 1860 Democratic convention which took 57 ballots at Charleston and two more in Baltimore to nominate Stephen Douglas in a bitterly divided party in which Southern Democrats had walked out; the 1852 Democratic convention which took 49 ballots to nominate Franklin Pierce; the 1912 Democratic convention which took 46 ballots to nominate Woodrow Wilson; the 1920 Democratic convention which took 44 ballots to nominate James Cox; the 1880 Republican convention which took 36 ballots to nominate James A. Garfield; the 1868 Democratic convention which took 22 ballots to nominate Horatio Seymour; the 1920 Republican convention which took 10 ballots to nominate Warren G. Harding; and the 1844 Democratic convention which took 9 ballots to nominate James K. Polk. Five of these nine nominees went on to become President, including Democrats James K. Polk, Franklin Pierce, and Woodrow Wilson; and Republicans James A. Garfield and Warren G. Harding. Notice that the Democrats had seven of these nine most contested conventions, and both Republicans in such situations won the White House.
Since the last truly contested convention in 1952, three later conventions have been memorable, although not technically contested. The 1976 Republican convention is remembered because Gerald Ford won only slightly over Ronald Reagan, but he had the ability to win on the first ballot. The same applies to the 1968 Democratic convention, which was tumultuous, but Hubert Humphrey won on the first ballot over Eugene McCarthy and George McGovern. And the challenge by Ted Kennedy to Jimmy Carter in the 1980 Democratic convention did not prevent Carter from being nominated, although Carter lost the Presidency as a result of the intraparty split! Finally, realize that these more recent conventions that were somewhat contentious led to the defeat of all three Presidential candidates, including two Presidents, Ford and Carter, running for reelection!
comments powered by Disqus
- Male Historians Have Long Dominated Public Debates. Is Charlottesville a Turning Point?
- Kevin Levin says he’s changed his mind about Confederate statues
- Scholar of African history says his Jewish background didn’t stop him from writing about Muslims and Africa
- Jon Meacham points out why Lee should go but Washington should stay
- "I've studied the history of Confederate memorials. Here's what to do about them."