Blogs > Cliopatria > Dichotomies and ... Trichotomies?

Sep 11, 2004

Dichotomies and ... Trichotomies?




David Brooks, the master of conflated social and political dichotomy, has struck again, this time dividing Americans into"paragraph people" (humanities majors/Democrats) and"spreadsheet" people (CEOs/accountants/Republicans). Curiously, though, he cites figures showing that the vast majority of political donations from employees of certain institutions of higher learning went to Democrats, but surely these schools have business departments, economists, natural scientists, not to mention non-academic employees?

And Cornell West, who has explored more forms of media than most, has divided political elites into three kinds of nihilists: evangelical ("might makes right," not Christian), paternalistic ("because he pities the masses, he deceives them"), and sentimental (truth subordinate to narrative satisfaction). The evangelical nihilists seem to be mostly Republicans, though you could argue for any group self-satisfied at its own success. The paternalist examples given in the review are Democrats, but it seems to be a pretty good description of Straussian neo-conservativism [Thanks, Ralph], as well. The sentimental nihilists are identified with the media, but that has to include advertising/marketing and political rhetoreticians as well. I would be more inclined to take West's categories seriously -- I certainly think he's right that American democracy needs renewal and we have many traditions on which to draw to accomplish that, as well as new resources -- if he didn't attribute the withering souls of American youth to" cocaine, Ecstasy, oral sex and -- Weblogs."



comments powered by Disqus

More Comments:


Jonathan Dresner - 9/11/2004

No, it was a deliberate parallel with my description of David Brooks. I mean, I'd like to make a CD and be in movies, too, but....


Manan Ahmed - 9/11/2004

You mean lower than being in Matrix:Reloaded?


Ralph E. Luker - 9/11/2004

Good point, Manan. I'm just reporting the concensus of opinion I've read that the cd probably is the low, embarrassing point in the public career of a very capable scholar.


Manan Ahmed - 9/11/2004

Has anyone actually heard the cd? I'm just curious. Could be good...one never knows.


Ralph E. Luker - 9/11/2004

Touche'!


Michael C Tinkler - 9/11/2004

I do hope that in your "has explored more forms of media than most" you're not giving Prof. West credit for the rap cd? Some forms of personal exploration should be kept to the bedroom or the shower.