History News Network puts current events into historical perspective. Subscribe to our newsletter for new perspectives on the ways history continues to resonate in the present. Explore our archive of thousands of original op-eds and curated stories from around the web. Join us to learn more about the past, now.
Your comment surprises me, David. I'm sure you know of the critics of academic publications in both the social sciences and literary criticism as being full of insider jargon. A carnival is a periodic featuring of exemplary posts about a field of interest from a wide variety of blogs. I tend to post "link-heavy" posts here at Cliopatria, with the assumption that readers will left-click on those of interest. A visit or two to carnivals would make clear what they are. Otherwise, I am only semi-literate in blog-insider talk. Some of my colleagues here are capable of leaving both you and me wondering what the dickens they're talking about.
The "end of H-Net" flap gives me the opportunity to point out the obvious: we join electronic conversations and media at different times. For instance, although I am active on one blog (alcohol/drugs history) and contribute occasionally to others, I know very little about blogs. The terminology often baffles me. For instance, after following Cliopatria for a couple of years I still have no idea what a "carnival" is. In other words, blogs seem to foster an in-group conversation that is unaware that it is an in-group conversation. I contrast this to printed books and articles that strive to be intelligible to a fairly large audience.