Blogs Liberty and Power Latin Lover
Feb 27, 2004Latin Lover
Re Dave's Greek/Latin question:
I'm not sure what was the case during Jesus' time, but a couple of centuries later Greek was the common language of the eastern part of the Empire (including the Middle East and thus Judea) while Latin remained the common language of the western part (including western Europe).
What bugs me is that the Roman soldiers appear to be speaking ecclesiastical Latin rather than classical Latin. When Pilate tells the crowd"ecce homo," he pronounces the" cc" soft, as in medieval Latin and modern Italian. But during that period the" cc" would still have been pronounced hard --"eck-ay" rather than"etch-ay." Gibson makes his Romans sound like Catholic priests!
This would seem a minor glitch to most people, but to a classicist it's like Washington crossing the Potomac in a motorboat.
I'm not sure what was the case during Jesus' time, but a couple of centuries later Greek was the common language of the eastern part of the Empire (including the Middle East and thus Judea) while Latin remained the common language of the western part (including western Europe).
What bugs me is that the Roman soldiers appear to be speaking ecclesiastical Latin rather than classical Latin. When Pilate tells the crowd"ecce homo," he pronounces the" cc" soft, as in medieval Latin and modern Italian. But during that period the" cc" would still have been pronounced hard --"eck-ay" rather than"etch-ay." Gibson makes his Romans sound like Catholic priests!
This would seem a minor glitch to most people, but to a classicist it's like Washington crossing the Potomac in a motorboat.
comments powered by Disqus
News
- Health Researchers Show Segregation 100 Years Ago Harmed Black Health, and Effects Continue Today
- Understanding the Leading Thinkers of the New American Right
- Want to Understand the Internet? Consider the "Great Stink" of 1858 London
- As More Schools Ban "Maus," Art Spiegelman Fears Worse to Come
- PEN Condemns Censorship in Removal of Coates's Memoir from AP Course
- Should Medicine Discontinue Using Terminology Associated with Nazi Doctors?
- Michael Honey: Eig's MLK Bio Needed to Engage King's Belief in Labor Solidarity
- Blair L.M. Kelley Tells Black Working Class History Through Family
- Review: J.T. Roane Tells Black Philadelphia's History from the Margins
- Cash Reparations to Japanese Internees Helped Rebuild Autonomy and Dignity






