Blogs > Cliopatria > Things Noted Here and There

Aug 29, 2005

Things Noted Here and There




Notre Dame's loss is Oxford's gain. You recall that Tariq Ramadan, the distinguished Muslim scholar, was unable to take residency at Notre Dame last year because the Department of Homeland Security refused to approve his admission to the United States. Ramadan will become a Visiting Fellow at St. Anthony's College, Oxford, in October.

Have history professors been sidelined from helping to shape the nation's public school curriculum or have we sidelined ourselves? Christopher Shea,"History Lessons," Boston Globe, 28 August, explores the matter, following publication of Robert Orrill and Linn Shapiro's"From Bold Beginnings to an Uncertain Future: The Discipline of History and History Education," AHR, June 2005. Thanks to Sepoy at Chapati Mystery for the tip.

Pauline Maier,"The Founding Revisited," Washington Post, 28 August, reviews Edward Lengel's General George Washington: A Military Life and Gary Nash's The Unknown American Revolution: The Unruly Birth of Democracy and the Struggle to Create America. Maier is fairly critical of Nash's work, as Gordon Wood was in"Colonial Correctness," TNR, 6 June, and a half dozen Cliopatricians were in"America's Unfinished Revolution: A Symposium," 7 July 2005.

The Financial Times has an amusing piece, Virginia Marsh's"Lunch with the FT: The History Wars," 26 August. Ms. Marsh and pudgy, white, and self-satisfied Keith Windschuttle discuss his work and stuff themselves on a $139 lunch of oysters, kingfish salad, and blue eye cod. Windschuttle's blog, by the way, is The Sydney Line. Thanks to Alfredo Perez at Political Theory Daily Review for the tip.

Finally, Kevin Drum at Political Animal has a helpful map and explanation of the circumstances under which New Orleans could experience a catastrophic hit this morning from hurricane Katrina.



comments powered by Disqus

More Comments:


Van L. Hayhow - 8/30/2005

I tried it again. The articles I could open, it was the book reviews that would not open completely. When I posted before, it was only the book reviews I had tried to open. Thanks everyone.


Ralph E. Luker - 8/30/2005

Maybe I should try to get some official clarification from the editor of the _AHR_ and post it at Cliopatria.


Sharon Howard - 8/30/2005

Well, it says on the History Cooperative homepage that access to all articles in AHR has been made free to *everyone*. I've been able to read them anyway, and I'm not an AHA member. However (I missed this exception first time round), it doesn't apply to book reviews. Try checking out Ralph's link to the Orrill and Shapiro article and see what happens?


Jonathan Dresner - 8/29/2005

Access is actually restricted to AHA members (and some other folks, I think) though people can purchase temporary access as well.


Van L. Hayhow - 8/29/2005

Well I am not an historian (nor do I play one on TV) so this was good news for me. One problem though, when I went to the website I could only access the first paragraph or so of the articles. Anyone know what the story is? Am I doing something wrong? Is it not implemented yet? Thanks.


Sharon Howard - 8/29/2005

I'm quite sure that every historian in north America reading this already knew this, but I didn't till today, so it seems worth pointing out that online access to all articles in the American Historical Review (via the History Cooperative) has recently been made freely available. A terrific move by the AHA, I think.