Daniel Gross: Decline? I'll Decline.
The dumb, willfully blind optimists who dominated the late boom have been evicted—and the ardent declinists, the bears and the prophetic historians have moved in. They've come armed with copies of Gibbon and Malthus, and with data. If this is the typical financial-crisis-induced recession, economists Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff conclude, unemployment could spike to double digits through 2011, and the housing and stock markets won't rebound until the end of 2010.
As the government steps up its involvement with the financial sector, there's widespread concern that the U.S. may be losing some of its capitalistic essence. At Davos, Niall Ferguson, a brilliant young Oxford-educated, Ivy League–employed (Harvard) historian, said the U.S. isn't in a Great Depression. Rather, it's in the grips of a "Great Repression," in deep denial of its problems. The go-go Age of Leverage is over, and a go-slow Age of Big Government has begun. High levels of debt, imperial overreach and heightened government influence in the economy means the U.S. is in for a Japan-style lost decade, in which it could struggle to chart growth of 1 percent, Ferguson argued.
Economic prognostication is hamstrung by a tendency to extrapolate from recent trends endlessly into the future. It happens at the top of a cycle—the Dow is going to 36,000! Housing prices never fall!!—which helps explain how we find ourselves in this particular pickle. And it happens when we fall into a ditch.
History may not repeat itself. But it sure does rhyme. Historians rhyme, too. Twenty-two years ago, another young, Oxford-educated, Ivy League–employed (Yale) historian argued that America's best days were behind it, thanks to imperial overreach, excessive debt and an epic financial bust. Paul Kennedy's "The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers" was a bestseller when it was published in 1987—and went into paperback just as the U.S. was beginning to emerge from the Cold War as the world's only superpower and the hub of a global integrated trading system.
The cry of creeping socialism has likewise echoed (falsely) through the decades. In 1935, the day after Franklin Roosevelt delivered a fireside chat about the need for Social Security and other regulations, a U.S. Chamber of Commerce official accused Roosevelt of trying to "Sovietize America." The medical profession—and Ronald Reagan—swore up and down that the passage of Medicare and Medicaid would transform the United States into an English-speaking version of the U.S.S.R....
Read entire article at Newsweek
As the government steps up its involvement with the financial sector, there's widespread concern that the U.S. may be losing some of its capitalistic essence. At Davos, Niall Ferguson, a brilliant young Oxford-educated, Ivy League–employed (Harvard) historian, said the U.S. isn't in a Great Depression. Rather, it's in the grips of a "Great Repression," in deep denial of its problems. The go-go Age of Leverage is over, and a go-slow Age of Big Government has begun. High levels of debt, imperial overreach and heightened government influence in the economy means the U.S. is in for a Japan-style lost decade, in which it could struggle to chart growth of 1 percent, Ferguson argued.
Economic prognostication is hamstrung by a tendency to extrapolate from recent trends endlessly into the future. It happens at the top of a cycle—the Dow is going to 36,000! Housing prices never fall!!—which helps explain how we find ourselves in this particular pickle. And it happens when we fall into a ditch.
History may not repeat itself. But it sure does rhyme. Historians rhyme, too. Twenty-two years ago, another young, Oxford-educated, Ivy League–employed (Yale) historian argued that America's best days were behind it, thanks to imperial overreach, excessive debt and an epic financial bust. Paul Kennedy's "The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers" was a bestseller when it was published in 1987—and went into paperback just as the U.S. was beginning to emerge from the Cold War as the world's only superpower and the hub of a global integrated trading system.
The cry of creeping socialism has likewise echoed (falsely) through the decades. In 1935, the day after Franklin Roosevelt delivered a fireside chat about the need for Social Security and other regulations, a U.S. Chamber of Commerce official accused Roosevelt of trying to "Sovietize America." The medical profession—and Ronald Reagan—swore up and down that the passage of Medicare and Medicaid would transform the United States into an English-speaking version of the U.S.S.R....