Young Jews Are Rebelling on Israeli Heritage Trips

Birthright—or “Taglit,” meaning “discovery”—has provided free travel to Israel for more than 650,000young Jews since it was established, in 1999. Its proponents see the 10-day trips as vital in helping young Jews connect with their cultural identity and enjoying what the organization considers its collective heritage.

But the popular activity is facing accusations of bias, dishonesty and ignorance from the very people it is trying to attract. In recent weeks, young Jewish people have publicly railed against the institution. On two separate occasions in the past month, participants abandoned Birthright in the middle of their tours, filming the moment they walked out. The rebels then headed for Palestinian areas to experience what they said was a more authentic and honest portrayal of the political situation in the country.

Eight Birthright attendees from two separate groups walked off their tour Sunday. One of the groups live-streamed the moment they left, announcing to the group, “This is a real rare opportunity for us to listen and learn and take a stand against endless occupation, and for freedom and equality.”