Joseph Ellis weighs in on ISISHistorians in the News
tags: ISIS, Joseph Ellis
To the Editor:
Re “ISIS Is Losing in Iraq. But What Happens Next?” (Op-Ed, Feb. 4):
Kenneth M. Pollack recognizes that any military victory over the Islamic State would not resolve the political crisis in Iraq because, as he puts it, “political reconciliation between the Sunni and Shiite communities is at a standstill.” And he worries that defeating ISIS “would not end the slow-burning Iraqi civil war, but inflame it.”
I concur, but reject his recommendation that only the United States can broker an agreement between the rival sects that permits a functional Iraqi government to emerge after a defeated ISIS.
Despite what Mr. Pollock suggests, the core problem is not Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki’s misguided oppression of Sunnis from 2010 to 2014, which is like blaming a leaky toilet in Altoona for the Johnstown Flood in 1889. The problem goes back over a thousand years.
By removing Saddam Hussein, we exposed the unpalatable but undeniable fact that there is no such thing as the Iraqi people and never has been. The current Iraqi government is really a Shiite government, democratically elected, to be sure, because it is the majority sect.
We must face the fact that we created this intractable mess, and the only political solution is the partition of Iraq into three semiautonomous regions. The Kurds already understand this. A long and bloody civil war between the Sunnis and Shiites is probably necessary before they embrace the inevitable outcome.
Any American political or military presence in that conflict will only worsen and extend the violence and repeat the tragic blunder that triggered the current chaos.
JOSEPH J. ELLIS
comments powered by Disqus
- Raw Fish and Tapeworms: Ancient Latrines Reveal the Diets of Our Ancestors
- Sam Houston Could Soon Be Getting His Own Presidential Library
- Trump delays release of some JFK assassination files until 2021, bowing to national security concerns
- A Lynching Memorial Is Opening. The Country HasNever Seen Anything Like It.
- Gina Haspel’s CIA Torture File
- Historian Erik Loomis makes the case for a federal jobs guarantee
- Michael Beschloss says this isn't the most politically divisive time in America
- This is what happened when a historian with a rural background wrote favorably about gun control in the Washington Post
- Is Economics Going Back To The 1800s? Maybe So.
- Historian: Why destroying archives is never a good idea