With support from the University of Richmond

History News Network

History News Network puts current events into historical perspective. Subscribe to our newsletter for new perspectives on the ways history continues to resonate in the present. Explore our archive of thousands of original op-eds and curated stories from around the web. Join us to learn more about the past, now.

How James Monroe Policies Might Help Obama Triumph over Foreign Foes

As President Obama struggles to end threats to American security in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, Iraq and North Korea, he might find solutions in policies that one of his earliest predecessors, James Monroe, implemented to crush similar threats to our nation.

Fifth president of the United States, Monroe had been a heroic officer during the Revolutionary War, suffering a serious wound at the Battle of Trenton and surviving the bitter winter at Valley Forge. He won election to the Presidency two years after the War of 1812, which President James Madison had provoked by invading Canada. Before it ended, a British invasion left the public buildings in Washington gutted by fire.

With British troops still poised to attack the nation from the north, Spanish troops threatening from the South, and Indian tribes slaughtering farmers in the West, Monroe abandoned Madison’s warlike policies in favor of strong defensive measures to make the nation impregnable to attack by foreign enemies. He reinforced existing defenses, then expanded our national boundaries to the natural defenses of the oceans, lakes, rivers, and mountains that rimmed the continent. He sent Andrew Jackson and a small army to seize Florida from Spain and force Spain to redraw western boundaries of the Louisiana territory to extend U. S. dominion westward to the protection of the Rocky Mountains and the Pacific Ocean.

For the first time since they declared independence from Britain, Americans were secure from attack by foreign troops, and they streamed westward across the Appalachian Mountains to claim their share of America, buying up wilderness lands from the government and carving out farms, harvesting furs and pelts from abundant wildlife, culling timber from rich forests, and chiseling ore from mountainsides. In an era when land—not money—was wealth, the land rush added six states to the Union and produced the largest redistribution of wealth in the annals of man. Never before in history had a sovereign state transferred ownership of so much land—and so much political power—to so many people not of noble rank.

To ensure success for the land rush and perpetuate economic growth, Monroe promoted construction of roads, turnpikes, bridges and canals that linked every region of the nation with outlets to the sea and shipping routes to the world. The massive building programs transformed the American wilderness into the most prosperous, productive nation in history. The economic recovery converted U.S. government deficits into such large surpluses that Monroe abolished all personal federal taxes in America.

Monroe’s presidency made poor men rich, and encouraged the arts, literature, music and fine art. He turned political allies into friends, and united a divided people as no president had done since George Washington and never would again until, perhaps, the Second World War. Political parties dissolved and disappeared. Americans of all political persuasions rallied around him and reelected him to the presidency in 1820 without opposition. He created an era never seen before or since in American history—an “Era of Good Feelings” that propelled the nation and its people to greatness.

After building American military and naval power to levels that made our shores impregnable, Monroe climaxed his presidency—and startled the world—with the most important political manifesto in American history after the Declaration of Independence:  the Monroe Doctrine. Monroe warned the world that the United States would no longer permit foreign incursions in the Americas. It was unprecedented in world history. The Monroe Doctrine (or more accurately, manifesto) unilaterally extended America’s sphere of influence over the entire Western Hemisphere—one-third of the globe. In effect, he told the world we would no longer meddle in their affairs, but they had best not meddle in ours. He told enemies and friends alike that they would profit far more by trading with us than trying to conquer us.

Several presidents in the Cold War era used—and misused—Monroe’s policies, all but losing the Cold War by invading Vietnam. The United States won the Cold War not by sending troops into eastern Europe or the Soviet Union, but by building anti-missile-missile defenses to make our shores all but impregnable to attack and building retaliatory capability to levels that made the Soviets realize they would profit far more by trading with us than attacking us. A similar policy might just convince the North Koreans, Iranians, and nations that host the Taliban and Al Qaeda to do the same. Like the end of the War of 1812, the end of the Cold War sparked unprecedented investments at home, unprecedented wealth for Americans, and the conversion of U.S. government deficits into surpluses. Ending troop involvement in the Middle East might well produce the same results.