Murray Polner: Review of Philip Gold's The Coming Draft: The Crisis in Our Military and Why Selective Service is Wrong for America (Ballantine Books)
When Jimmy Carter, intimidated by neoconservatives for being soft on Communism, foolishly reintroduced draft registration to “send a signal” to the Russians after their invasion of Afghanistan it had no effect on Moscow. Within ten years the Soviet Union would collapse of its own incompetence and corruption, none of which had anything to do with draft registration (which because of bureaucratic lethargy and governmental stupidity, still continues wasting taxpayer money). To those in out of Washington still promoting a draft in the hope of deterring other “axis of evil” nations, the suggestion, Gold believes, is highly debatable.
No draft is fair. Nor will many want to serve in Iraq, Iran, North Korea or anywhere else without knowing why. No dove, Gold a onetime Marine officer (and “disaffected conservative”) who earned a Ph.D. in history from Georgetown and writes about national security issues, recognizes the serious problems whenever America has resorted to conscription.
Four million Americans turn eighteen every year. Should the current lottery system ever be utilized, how could a draft of say, 50,000 annually, be justified when all the rest are free to go about their civilian lives? No congressional son was drafted during Vietnam and virtually none of their kids -- as well as in the executive branch--are in the active military today. The same favoritism and deference to influence and wealth will certainly prevail in any future draft. Anyone with political contacts and family connections will always be able to avoid active military duty, or if not, receive plum jobs. What a draft does is simply encourage Washington’s homebound hawks.
For too many conservatives another draft means recapturing the mythical ethos of WWII and the pre-sixties. In that imaginary Eden, there was no racial or religious discrimination, women knew their place, support for tyrants abroad was justified in the name of fighting Communism and young men called to the colors went willingly and patriotically (I went when drafted, but neither willingly nor patriotically, nor did any draftee with whom I served). People, Gold acutely comments, need a “good enough reason” to go to serve in the military.
In his 2004 article he argued against a draft “save in extremis,” though that phrase is too vague. The way to avoid conscription is to avoid unnecessary wars and think twice about sending our men and women into battle in the name of “freedom and democracy” or another “war to end all wars.” Interventionists falsely call this “isolationism” but is it not a willingness to adopt a sane foreign policy that encourages peaceful, live and let live relations, while courting and finding common ground culturally, economically and diplomatically with potential rivals? It may not always work but it can’t be worse than America’s historic addiction to war and intervention. Philip Gold is right. Another draft is a mindless idea in a very troubled time.
comments powered by Disqus
Carl Becker - 1/23/2007
The twin bills, S89 and HR163 have been in process since 2003 and there have been supporters in the past from both political parties. However, the bills will never pass; it’s bad theater and fuzzy thinking. We already have “drafts” on-going in this country anyway sponsored by both Republican and Democrats: National Guard/Reserve draft, you could end up in Iraq, IRR draft, you can end up in Iraq, Stop-Loss draft, you may never leave Iraq,…to name a few, the joke’s on the people.
Tim R. Furnish - 1/22/2007
The last time I checked, the only person(s) to introduce Congressional bills for resurrecting the draft were....Democrats--most notably Charlie Wrangel (D-NY). What is the evidence that "necons" and "conservatives" harbor a desire to impose a new draft?
- Hull of Confederate Submarine H.L. Hunley Found 150 Years Later
- U.S. Textbook Skews History, Prime Minister of Japan Says
- Recalling a Film From the Liberation of the Camps
- Skull Fossil Offers New Clues on Human Journey From Africa
- Are crude conspiracies right? Research shows nations really do go to war over oil
- Columbia University professors Eric Foner, Alan Brinkley, and Alice Kessler-Harris to retire
- A powerhouse appropriations subcommittee is now headed by a historian: Republican Rep. Tom Cole (OK)
- Slavic scholars divided over a scholarship sponsored (and withdrawn) by Stephen F. Cohen
- Claire Strom to Step Down as Editor of Agricultural History