Why Mary Is the Mother We Celebrate the Rest of the YearHistorians/History
Ten years ago I began an historical study of the figure of the Virgin Mary. I am a historian of the Middle Ages, and so I expected my work to include the study of religious imagery and prayer, hymns and Marian shrines. I also expected the most passionate interest in the figure of Mary to arise among women: working women in families or religious women in nunneries, of high status and low. I looked forward to exploring worlds of personal devotion and family worship, and these I found all over Europe and in all social contexts. What I had not expected was the extent of public and even political power possessed by this quintessential figure of motherhood. Here was a challenge: motherhood acting in the public domain.
In large parts of the world Madonnas are still to be seen on every street corner. This figure of beauty and tenderness - a young mother – gazes adoringly at her son, cradles him, or offers him her breast. Yet this pair, so intimately coupled in their own private world, has historically represented much more than the attachment between mother and son, for in medieval Europe collective enterprises – pilgrimage, crusades, conquest and mission - came to be associated with the wholesome figure of the nurturing mother. One image of Mary associated her with charitable work: feeding the hungry, visiting the sick and comforting prisoners; another saw her as a protective shield against the misfortune caused by human sin. Churches and shrines which could convincingly claim possession of a vestige of Mary’s maternal body – milk, hair, girdle, tunic – were inundated by female pilgrims, mothers-to-be in search of a safe delivery.
Perhaps that is why non-Christians were attracted to the figure of Mary too. Despite the fact that Islam and Judaism were pitted in polemic and enmity against Christianity, Mary emerged as a profoundly attractive figure. For Muslims this was – and is – an easy point of contact, since the Quran extols Mary in a chapter devoted to her, the Sura Maryam. In areas where Christians and Muslims lived side by side – in Iberia, in Syria – they sometimes visited the same Mary shrines. With Jews the relationship was much more vexed, but here too there was a fascination with the art and praise of Mary: women may have drawn healing water from wells associated with Mary, and they may have borrowed from the lyrics in her honour to praise the Talmud, as a female figure.
Irreducible and familiar motherhood – nurturing and consoling – made Mary the most accessible aspect of Christian culture, as it became a global phenomenon. In the lands of conquest and conversion – Mexico, Peru, Quebec – missionaries led with the image of a pure and loving mother. This figure suggested ways of weaving communities together, as women do, through the sharing of food, by help in the tasks of caring for the young and the old, for the sick and the poor. Motherhood is a way of being which transcends the intimacy of mother and offspring; it is a habit of radical hospitality, of generosity.
The most common images of motherhood around us these days aim at promoting consumption: commercials present mother at the dinner table, operating the washing machine, or driving the family car on the school run. Here is the contemporary mother, proficient at all tasks. Yet even these simplistic images hint at the vast back-story of care that exists beyond the household, which extends to neighbourhoods and into communities. Even in that most unusual of households - the White House - it seems right for a mother to be leading a group of neighbours in turning ornamental soil into a vegetable garden.
To cherish motherhood as a social force is not to privilege women over men, but rather to understand in a new way that charity and amity do begin at home. Motherhood’s radical impulse towards empathy and sharing is a human resource. It is rooted in the domestic but can transcend into wider spheres. Most cultures over many centuries have relegated it to the household. It is ripe to be realized as one of our least fully exploited social forces.
comments powered by Disqus
Lorraine Paul - 5/14/2009
Thanks, Jonathan. However, I was referring to Islamic 'enmity' against Christians.
I agree wholeheartedly that Christianity has had little respect for Islam, or any other religion if it comes to that.
There was a documentary recently on television, and although I am always sus where these are concerned as they invariably present a one-sided view, it did not surprise me that it was about a young Jewish boy who was virtually kidnapped from his family by none other than the Pope himself. Apparently this didn't happen in medieval times, but in the late 19thC.
Jonathan Dresner - 5/12/2009
I'm not an expert, but I do know that there's a long tradition of Christian polemics against Islam, which often bled over into popular culture: For example, the position of the Prophet Mohammed in Hell in Dante's Inferno.
Lorraine Paul - 5/11/2009
As Jesus is honoured as a prophet in the Quran, where does the 'polemic enmity' regarding Islam and Christianity occur? Perhaps in some people's minds?
Jonathan Dresner - 5/11/2009
I'm perplexed by this passage:
With Jews the relationship was much more vexed, but here too there was a fascination with the art and praise of Mary: women may have drawn healing water from wells associated with Mary, and they may have borrowed from the lyrics in her honour to praise the Talmud, as a female figure.
I did some searching in the book, and found nothing to support this. It seems speculative -- conditionals on both evidentiary clauses -- as well as indirect (literary borrowing does not necessarily indicate anything about the source) and overblown ("fascination" suggests a wider interest, but the evidence, even read generously, suggests a minor phenomenon, at best).
I understand the desire to be ecumenical in scope, but evidence would help.
Nancy REYES - 5/11/2009
"Reigious women in nunneries"?
That phrase has anti caholic connotations a la "Maria Monk".
As for Mary, for ordinary Catholics Mary is the mama who will sneak us into heaven despite the big bad God with all those rules we can't manage to follow.
Check Andrew Greeley's book on the subject.
- A New Target for Old Spies: Congress
- Antigua and Barbuda Asks Harvard University for Slavery Reparations
- Historian: Nixon DID contest the 1960 election
- Killer took selfie after stabbing historian over rare ‘Wind in the Willows’ book
- VW fires corporate historian who drew attention to wartime ties to Nazis
- Historian Jeremy Kuzmarov calls on Obama to pardon Ethel Rosenberg
- Garry Wills says there’s one human test we can use to decide who’s the better candidate: Trump or Clinton
- Get to Know the Semifinalists for the National Book Award
- Steven Runciman — historian, tease and professional enigma — is the subject of a biography
- Historian Eric Foner: Trump is Logical Conclusion of What the GOP Has Been Doing for Decades