The case against reparationsRoundup
Several weeks back, Ta-Nehisi Coates, the Atlantic magazine's national correspondent, wrote a long piece, "The Case for Reparations," which seemed designed to ignite a discussion about compensation to African-Americans that we never had.
Except for a few corners of the Internet, it quickly evaporated.
I think I know why.
First, the Atlantic indulged Coates with 16,000 words to present a catalog of crimes against black Americans from slavery (mostly in the South) to redlining (mostly in the North). That was too long for most Americans.
Second, Coates never put a price tag on it.
Coates quotes black victims and white bigots. He mentions Congress' refusal to take up HR40, the Commission to Study Reparation Proposals for African-Americans Act, introduced annually since 1989 by U.S. Rep. John Conyers of Michigan.
Proponents say that "it's just a study." Critics doubt it will stop at "study.”...
Coates admits that the concept of reparations founders on questions such as who will be paid, how much will they get and who will pay them.
Would I be required to send money to Oprah Winfrey as reparations for slavery, which I did not cause and which she did not endure?
Most Americans know that African-Americans - most of whom have deeper roots in this nation than the rest of us - have suffered greatly in the past and face remnants of racism today. I believe that most Americans, if given a sensible and effective way to make amends, would take it.
Others say that our good faith was proved in a Civil War and by laws to create equality in housing, voting, jobs and education.
Coates says, "Reparations - by which I mean the full acceptance of our collective biography and its consequences - is the price we must pay to see ourselves squarely." That's it?
No. He adds: "The payment of reparations would represent America's maturation out of the childhood myth of its innocence into a wisdom worthy of its founders."
The founders' wisdom? The guys who permitted slavery? Does Coates think there are slavery deniers, as there are Holocaust deniers?...
comments powered by Disqus
- Karen L. Cox says historians shouldn’t be afraid to embrace YouTube to reach millennials
- You Know Your History? These Podcasts Aren’t So Sure.
- Victor Davis Hanson says Trump Must "Retire as Twitter Champ”
- The Daily Mail is highlighting claims by a Cambridge don that teachers are helping to foster resentment by presenting history as the struggle of minority groups
- Historians Are Calling Out Trump Online Whenever He Misreads the Past